**6. Conclusion**

28 Recent Advances in Crystallography

(j) Goldschmidt, 1913.

hidden faces (Figure 11c). This became standard. Twinning and concavities appeared in

**Figure 10.** Crystal model making devices. From left to right: Fuess, 1889; Goldschmidt, 1908; Stöber, 1914.

**Figure 11.** Crystal drawing from Schuh, 2007c. (a) Boodt, 1647; (b) Linneaus, 1768; (c) Haüy, 1801; (d) Dana, 1837; (e) Mohs, 1825; (f) Naumann, 1830; (g) Kopp, 1849; (h) Koksharov, 1853; (i) Dana, 1877;

later plates, especially those of Dana in his *System of Mineralogy* (1877) (Figure 11i).

The range and detail of Schuh's *History,* supported by the *Biobibliography*, is unlikely to be surpassed for a very long time. It is an extraordinary achievement that deserves wider notice. It is the single narrative in English that we felt was lacking when we began the translation of Shafranovskii. The chasm is filled. The considerable effort of a full translation

#### 30 Recent Advances in Crystallography

of Shafranovskii is not longer as urgent (if it ever was). We now terminate our translation project, having introduced English readers to the flavor of Shafranovskii's history, the most complete work of its kind until that of Curtis P. Schuh.

### **Author details**

Bart Kahr and Alexander G. Shtukenberg *Department of Chemistry, New York University, New York City, USA* 

## **7. References**

Agricola, G. (1556) De Re Metallica, Basil.


Batyushkova, I. V. (Ed.) (1973) The History of Geology, Nauka, Moscow, (in Russian).


www.findagrave.com/cgi-bin/fg.cgi?page=gr&GRid=25238101.

Curie, M. (1923) Pierre Curie, Macmillan, New York

30 Recent Advances in Crystallography

**Author details** 

**7. References** 

complete work of its kind until that of Curtis P. Schuh.

*Department of Chemistry, New York University, New York City, USA* 

Al-Biruni, (1989) On Precious Stones, Pakistani Hijra Council, Islamabad.

Physics Crystallography, Vol. 12, pp. 335-336, ISSN: 0038-5638.

Physics Crystallography, Vol. 22, pp. 386-387, ISSN: 0038-5638.

Bertuch, F. J. (1798) Bilderbuch für Kinder, Industre-Comptoir, Weimar.

Boodt, A. B. de (1647) Gemmarum et Lapidum Historia, Joannis Maire.

Mathématiques pures et Appliquées, Vol. 14, pp. 137-140. Bravais, A. (1866) Études crystallographiques, Gauthier-Villars, Paris.

Physics Crystallography, Vol. 32, pp. 771, ISSN: 0038-5638.

refractio detegitur, Daniel Paulli, Copenhagen.

Soviet Physics Crystallography, Vol. 2, pp. 665-666, ISSN: 0038-5638.

Bart Kahr and Alexander G. Shtukenberg

Agricola, G. (1556) De Re Metallica, Basil.

B0060T2202, New York.

Dieterich, Gota.

New York.

Moscow, p. 5-6 (in Russian).

of Shafranovskii is not longer as urgent (if it ever was). We now terminate our translation project, having introduced English readers to the flavor of Shafranovskii's history, the most

Agricola, G. (1950) De Re Metallica, Hoover, H. C.; Hoover, L. H. trans. Dover, ASIN:

Anonymous (1957) Illarion Illarionovich Shafranovskii (on the occasion of his 50th birthday),

Anonymous (1967) Illarion Illarionovich Shafranovskii (on his sixtieth birthday), Soviet

Anonymous (1977) Illarion Illarionovich Shafranovskii (on his seventieth birthday), Soviet

Anonymous (1987) Illarion Illarionovich Shafranovskii: eightieth birthday greeting, Soviet

Bartholinus, E. (1669) Experimenta crystalli islandici disdiaclastici quibus mira & insolita

Bartholinus, E. (1959) Experiments with the double refracting Iceland crystal which led to the discovery of a marvelous and strange refraction, W. Brandt, trans. Westtown, Pa.

Baumesiter, J. A. I. E. von (1763) Naturgeschichte des Mineralreich, Johannes Christian

Belov, N. V. (1972) Foreword. In: Koslova, O. G. Growth and Morphology of Crystals,

Bokii, G. B., Shafranovskii, I. I. (1951) From correspondence between E. S. Fedorov and A.

Bragg, W. L. (1993) The Development of X-ray Analysis, Dover, ISBN-13: 978-0486673165,

Bravais, A. (1849) Note sur les polyèdres symétriques de la géométrie. Journal de

Schoenflies. In: Scientific Heritage, Vol. 2. Moscow, pp. 314-343 (in Russian).

Batyushkova, I. V. (Ed.) (1973) The History of Geology, Nauka, Moscow, (in Russian).

(http://etext.virginia.edu/toc/modeng/public/CurPier.html).


32 Recent Advances in Crystallography

9004092105 Leiden.

181-185. ISSN: 0077-7757.

Series 2, Vol. 4, pp. 112-200.

pp. 573-576. ISSN: 0044-2968.

Press, Moscow (in Russian).

ISBN:0-I9-8I4687-6, Oxford, p 187.

Vol. 9, No. 1, 43-58, ISSN: 1439-7641.

Heidelberg.

Springer, Berlin.

Schwickert, Leipzig.

ISSN: 1439-7641.

Russian).

163.

Figurovsky, N. A. (1969) Outlines of the General History of Chemistry, Nauka, Moscow (in

Fink, K. J. (1991) Goethe's History of Science, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge; p

Fuess, R. (1889) Über eine Orientirungsvorrichtung zum Schneiden und Schleifen von Mineralien nach bestimmten Richtungen, Neues Jahrbuch der Mineralogie, part 2, pp.

Gadolin, A. V. (1867) Deduction of all crystallographic systems and their subdivisions by means of a single general principle, Ann. Imp. St. Peteresberg Mineralogical Society,

Gibbs, J. W. (1878) On the equilibrium of heterogeneous substances, Transactions of the

Goldschmidt, V. (1908) Krystall-Modellierapparat 2. Zeitschrift für Krystallographie, Vol. 45,

Goldschmidt, V. (1913) Atlas der Krystallformen, Carl Winters Universitätsbuchhandlung,

Grigoriev, D. P. & Shafranovskii, I. I. (1949) Outstanding Russian Mineralogists, Academy of

Groth, P. v. (1906-1919) Chemische Kristallographie, Vol. I-V, Wilhelm Engelmann, Leipzig,. Groth, P. v. (1926) Entwicklungsgeschichte der mineralogischen Wissenschaften, Julius

Haüy, R. J. (1817) Sur l'électricité produite dans les minéraux à l'aide de la pression,

Healy, J. F. (1999) Pliny the Elder on Science and Technology, Oxford University Press,

Hessel, J. F. C. (1831) Krystallometrie oder Krystallonomie und Krystallographie, E. B.

Kahr, B. (2011) Murder charges against close-pack, Crystal Growth Design*,* Vol. 11, pp. 4-11. Kahr, B.; Arteaga, O. (2012) Arago's best paper, ChemPhysChem, Vol. 13, No. 1, pp. 79-88;

Kahr, B.; Claborn, K. (2008) The lives of Malus and his bicentennial law, ChemPhysChem,

Goldschmidt, V. M. (1937) Crystal Chemistry, Khimtheoretisdat, Leningrad (in Russian). Gordeev, D. I. (1967) The History of Geological Sciences, Vol. 1. Moscow State University

Connecticut Academy of Sciences, Vol. 3, pp. 108-248 & 353-524.

Sciences Press, USSR, Moscow, Leningrad (in Russian).

Haüy, R. J. (1801) Traité de Minéralogie, Chez Louis, Paris.

Hamlin, A. C. (1873) The Tourmaline, James R. Osgood & Co. London.

Mémoires de le Museum D'histoire naturelle, Vol. III, pp. 223-228.

Frankenheim, M. L. (1842) System der Krystalle, Von Grass, Barth und Comp. Breslau. Freudenthal, G. ed. (1990) Études Sur/Studies on Hélène Metzger*,* Brill, ISBN-13: 978-


Schoenflies, A. (1891) Kristallsysteme und Kristallstruktur, Teubner Verlag, Leipzig.

Schreibers, K. A. F. R. v. (1820) Beiträge zur Geschichte und Kenntniß meteorischer Stein und Metall Massen und der Erscheinungen welche deren Niederfallen zu begleiten pflegen, J. G. Heubner, Wien.

Schuh, C. P. (2007a) Mineralogy & Crystallography: On the History of These Sciences From Beginnings Through 1919, archives.org:

http://www.archive.org/details/History\_Mineralogy\_2007.

Schuh, C. P. (2007b) Mineralogy & Crystallography: An Annotated Biobibliography of Books Published 1469 through 1919, Volume I, archives.org:

http://www.archive.org/details/BioBib\_Mineralogy\_2007\_Vol\_1.

Schuh, C. P. (2007c) Mineralogy & Crystallography: An Annotated Biobibliography of Books Published 1469 through 1919, Volume II, archives.org:

http://www.archive.org/details/BioBib\_Mineralogy\_2007\_Vol\_2.


Shafranovskii, I. I. & Belov, N. V. (1962) In Memoriam: E.S. Fedorov, Fifty years of X-ray diffraction, pp. 341-350, Ewald, P.P. ed. International Union of Crystallographers, ISBN-13: 978- 9027790293, Utrecht.

34 Recent Advances in Crystallography

pflegen, J. G. Heubner, Wien.

Beginnings Through 1919, archives.org:

http://www.archive.org/details/History\_Mineralogy\_2007.

Published 1469 through 1919, Volume II, archives.org: http://www.archive.org/details/BioBib\_Mineralogy\_2007\_Vol\_2.

& J. Wetstenium, & Gul. Smith, Amsterdam.

House, Leningrad (in Russian).

Moscow, Leningrad (in Russian).

Nauka, Leningrad (in Russian).

Nauka, Leningrad (in Russian).

and Anatomist, Nauka, Leningrad (in Russian).

Russian).

Washington D.C.

Russian).

Books Published 1469 through 1919, Volume I, archives.org: http://www.archive.org/details/BioBib\_Mineralogy\_2007\_Vol\_1.

of Natural and Engineering Sciences, Moscow, Vol. 19, pp. 84-94. Shafranovskii, I. I. (1964) Diamonds, Nauka, Moscow, Leningrad (in Russian).

Schoenflies, A. (1891) Kristallsysteme und Kristallstruktur, Teubner Verlag, Leipzig.

Schreibers, K. A. F. R. v. (1820) Beiträge zur Geschichte und Kenntniß meteorischer Stein und Metall Massen und der Erscheinungen welche deren Niederfallen zu begleiten

Schuh, C. P. (2007a) Mineralogy & Crystallography: On the History of These Sciences From

Schuh, C. P. (2007b) Mineralogy & Crystallography: An Annotated Biobibliography of

Schuh, C. P. (2007c) Mineralogy & Crystallography: An Annotated Biobibliography of Books

Seba, A. (1734) Locupletissimi Rerum Naturalium Thesauri, Apud Janssonio-Waesbergios,

Shafranovskii, I. I. (1962) History of Crystallography in Russia, Leningrad State Publishing

Shafranovskii, I. I. (1963) Evgraf Stepanovich Fedorov, Academy of Science Press, USSR,

Shafranovskii, I. I. (1964) Nikolai Ivanovich Koksharov, Nauka, Moscow, Leningrad (in

Shafranovskii, I. I. (1968a) A. G. Werner: A Famous Mineralogist and Geologist (1749-1817),

Shafronoviskii, I. I. (1972) Nicolaus Steno: A Crystallographer, Geologist, Paleontologist,

Shafranovskii, I. I. (1973) Lectures on Crystallomorphology, National Bureau of Standards,

Shafranovskii, I. I. (1974) Outlines of Mineralogical Crystallography, Nedra, Leningrad (in

Shafranovskii, I. I. (1975) Kepler's crystallographic ideas and his tract "The six-cornered

Shafranovskii, I. I. (1978) The History of Crystallography. Vol. I. From Ancient Times to the

Shafranovskii, I. I. (1980) The History of Crystallography. Vol. II. The Nineteenth Century,

Shafranovskii, I. I. (1968b) Symmetry in Nature, Nedra, Leningrad (in Russian).

snowflake", Vistas in Astronomy, Vol. 18, pp. 861-876, ISSN: 0083-6656.

Beginning of the Nineteenth Century, Nauka, Leningrad (in Russian).

Shafranovskii, I. I. (1952) Mineral Crystals, Leningrad State Publishing House, Leningrad. Shafranovskii, I. I. (1957) Pierre Curie – Crystallographer. Papers of the Institute of History

