**Bibliometric Analysis of Thermodynamic Research: A Science Citation Index Expanded-Based Analysis**

Hui-Zhen Fu and Yuh-Shan Ho

Additional information is available at the end of the chapter

http://dx.doi.org/10.5772/48360

## **1. Introduction**

18 Will-be-set-by-IN-TECH

[49] C.E. Shannon and W. Weaver, The mathematical theory of communications, University

[44] A. Ashtekar, J. C. Baez and K. Krasnov, Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 4 (2000) 1. [45] J. Fernando Barbero G. and E.J.S. Villasenor, gr-qc/1106.3179 preprint (2011).

[47] M. Banados, C. Teitelboim, J. Zanelli, Phys.Rev.Lett. 72 (1994) 957. [48] Steven Carlip, Claudio Teitelboim, Class.Quant.Grav. 12 (1995) 1699.

[42] K. V. Krasnov, Gen. Rel. Grav. 30 (1998) 53. [43] K. V. Krasnov, Class. Quant. Grav. 16 (1999) 563.

of Illinois Press, Urbana (1949). [50] E.T. Jaynes, Phys.Rev. 106 (1957) 620. [51] E.T. Jaynes, Phys.Rev. 108 (1957) 171. [52] J. D. Bekenstein, Phys. Rev. D 7 (1973) 2333. [53] S. Hod, Phys.Rev.D 61 (2000) 124016. [54] S. Hod, Phys. Lett. A 299, (2002) 144. [55] W. H. Zurek, Phys. Rev. Lett. 49 (1982) 1683. [56] D.N. Page, Phys.Rev.D 13 (1976) 198. [57] D.N. Page, Phys.Rev.D 14 (1976) 3260. [58] D.N. Page, Phys.Rev.D 16 (1977) 2402.

[46] S. Massar, R. Parentani , Nucl.Phys.B 575 (2000) 333.

Thermodynamics is the study of energy and its transformation (Holman, 1985). This subject has evolved since the beginning of the eighteenth century (Look & Saucer, 1982). Most studies of thermodynamics are primarily concerned with two forms of energy: heat and work (Holman, 1985; Keizer, 1985; Rosakis et al., 2000). Thermodynamics advanced dramatically in the 1960s and 1970s, primarily in the area of critical phenomena (Callen, 1985). In recent years, thermodynamic research has been conducted in more systems, such as corn-ethanol biofuel cycle (Patzek, 2004), lipid-peptide interactions (Seelig, 2004), DNA structural motifs (SantaLucia & Hicks, 2004), and glass-forming substances (Ngai, 2000).

Bibliometrics, as a measure of scientific performance, has been widely applied to research evaluation for a long period (Saracevi & Perk, 1973; Luukkonen, 1990; Friedberg, 2000). It has been employed to evaluate various researches, for example biology (Sainte-Marie 2010), desalination research (Tanaka & Ho, 2011), solid waste research (Fu et al., 2010), acupuncture research (Han & Ho, 2011), and global climate change (Li et al., 2011). In exited bibliometric analyses, the analyzed aspects usually covering languages (Alfaraz & Calvino, 2004; Chiu & Ho, 2007; Ferrara, 2011), annual publication outputs (Chiu & Ho, 2007; Tsay, 2008), journals (Schubert et al., 1989; Tsay, 2008), categories (Moed et al., 1995; Yamazaki, 1994), and contributing countries and institutions (Schubert et al., 1989; Chiu & Ho, 2007; Tanaka & Ho, 2011; Li et al., 2011). In recent years, author keywords which could provide a reasonably detailed picture of the article's subject (Garfield, 1990), have been quantitatively analyzed to figure out the research emphases and trends (Chiu & Ho, 2007; Fu et al., 2010; Li

© 2012 Fu and Ho, licensee InTech. This is an open access chapter distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. © 2012 The Author(s). Licensee InTech. This chapter is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

et al., 2011). To analyze these aspects, the common evaluation indicators number of publications and their publication share were utilized (Schubert et al., 1989; Rehn et al., 2007). Impact factor was introduced by Garfield and Sher (1963) to help select additional source journals using the recent citations received from other journals, and has been also widely used to rank and evaluate journals (Garfield, 1996; Moed, 2002). In particular, the five indicators including total, independent, collaborative, first author, and corresponding author articles have been recently used to compare the publication performance of countries and institutions in the researched of Japanese lung cancer (Ho et al., 2010), solid waste research (Fu et al., 2010), desalination research (Tanaka & Ho, 2011), acupuncture research (Han & Ho, 2011), global climate change (Li et al., 2011), and estuary pollution (Sun et al., 2012). In addition, rankings are useful indicators, especially in terms of institutions and researchers in urgent demand by politics (Weingart, 2003). These indicators including number of publication, publication share, impact factor, rankings, and five newly indicators were utilized for the evaluation of thermodynamics research.

Bibliometric Analysis of Thermodynamic Research: A Science Citation Index Expanded-Based Analysis 521

Topic = "thermodynamic" or "thermodynamics" or "free energy change" or "enthalpy change" or

"thermodynamic", "thermodynamics", "free energy change", "enthalpy change", and "entropy change" in front page (title, abstract, and author

Finally, the journal articles (41,245) were extracted from the 50,865 documents for

"entropy change" Lemmatization = off Year published = 1991-2010

keywords)

The analyzing aspects were divided into five sections from different angles. To be specific, the analytic structure of analytic structure of bibliometric analysis of thermodynamic research is presented in Fig. 2. The first section dealt with the basic information covering the distribution of languages and annual production. The second section revealed the performance of productive journals and Web of Science categories. Then national contributors countries and institutional contributors institutions were analyzed in the following third and fourth sections. Finally, recent research emphases and trends were

**Figure 1.** Data collection process for searching thermodynamic related research

50865 documents Document type = article

**Figure 2.** Analytic structure of bibliometric analysis of thermodynamic research

subsequent analyses.

Web of Science SCI-Expanded

157140 documents

41245 articles

**2.2. Analyzing structure** 

examined by the frequency of author keywords.

The aim of this study was to systematically evaluate not only the publication characteristics of languages, annual publication outputs, journals and Web of Science categories, and national and inter-institutional contributors, but also the research emphases and trends by author keywords to obtain an overview of thermodynamic research during the period from 1991 to 2010.

## **2. Methodology**

## **2.1. Data collection**

Documents used in this study were derived from the Science Citation Index Expanded (SCI-Expanded) database of the Web of Science, the Thomson Reuters. According to Journal Citation Reports (JCR), it indexes 8,073 journals with citation references across 174 scientific disciplines in 2010. The data was collected on November 20 in 2011, and the detail data collection process is illustrated in Fig. 1. Firstly, thermodynamics related keywords including "thermodynamic", "thermodynamics", "free energy change", "enthalpy change", and "entropy change" were searched in terms of topic (including four parts: title, abstract, author keywords, and KeyWords Plus) within the publication year limitation from 1991 to 2010 based on SCI-Expanded. Total 157,140 documents were therefore found out. However, these 157,140 documents contained the documents not closely relating to thermodynamics which was searched only in terms of KeyWords Plus which providing search terms extracted from the titles of papers cited in each new article listed in *Current Contents* (Garfield, 1990). To efficiently obtain the characteristics of thermodynamics, this study only focused on the documents (50,865) with searching keywords in front page which including three parts: title, abstract, and author keywords, while the documents where searching keywords only appeared in KeyWords Plus were excluded. These documents consists of 19 document types, where articles (41,245) dominants with a percentage of 81%, followed by proceedings paper (4,860; 10%), meeting abstract (1,787; 3.5%), and review (1,407; 2.8%). Finally, the journal articles (41,245) were extracted from the 50,865 documents for subsequent analyses.

**Figure 1.** Data collection process for searching thermodynamic related research

## **2.2. Analyzing structure**

520 Thermodynamics – Fundamentals and Its Application in Science

were utilized for the evaluation of thermodynamics research.

1991 to 2010.

**2. Methodology** 

**2.1. Data collection** 

et al., 2011). To analyze these aspects, the common evaluation indicators number of publications and their publication share were utilized (Schubert et al., 1989; Rehn et al., 2007). Impact factor was introduced by Garfield and Sher (1963) to help select additional source journals using the recent citations received from other journals, and has been also widely used to rank and evaluate journals (Garfield, 1996; Moed, 2002). In particular, the five indicators including total, independent, collaborative, first author, and corresponding author articles have been recently used to compare the publication performance of countries and institutions in the researched of Japanese lung cancer (Ho et al., 2010), solid waste research (Fu et al., 2010), desalination research (Tanaka & Ho, 2011), acupuncture research (Han & Ho, 2011), global climate change (Li et al., 2011), and estuary pollution (Sun et al., 2012). In addition, rankings are useful indicators, especially in terms of institutions and researchers in urgent demand by politics (Weingart, 2003). These indicators including number of publication, publication share, impact factor, rankings, and five newly indicators

The aim of this study was to systematically evaluate not only the publication characteristics of languages, annual publication outputs, journals and Web of Science categories, and national and inter-institutional contributors, but also the research emphases and trends by author keywords to obtain an overview of thermodynamic research during the period from

Documents used in this study were derived from the Science Citation Index Expanded (SCI-Expanded) database of the Web of Science, the Thomson Reuters. According to Journal Citation Reports (JCR), it indexes 8,073 journals with citation references across 174 scientific disciplines in 2010. The data was collected on November 20 in 2011, and the detail data collection process is illustrated in Fig. 1. Firstly, thermodynamics related keywords including "thermodynamic", "thermodynamics", "free energy change", "enthalpy change", and "entropy change" were searched in terms of topic (including four parts: title, abstract, author keywords, and KeyWords Plus) within the publication year limitation from 1991 to 2010 based on SCI-Expanded. Total 157,140 documents were therefore found out. However, these 157,140 documents contained the documents not closely relating to thermodynamics which was searched only in terms of KeyWords Plus which providing search terms extracted from the titles of papers cited in each new article listed in *Current Contents* (Garfield, 1990). To efficiently obtain the characteristics of thermodynamics, this study only focused on the documents (50,865) with searching keywords in front page which including three parts: title, abstract, and author keywords, while the documents where searching keywords only appeared in KeyWords Plus were excluded. These documents consists of 19 document types, where articles (41,245) dominants with a percentage of 81%, followed by proceedings paper (4,860; 10%), meeting abstract (1,787; 3.5%), and review (1,407; 2.8%). The analyzing aspects were divided into five sections from different angles. To be specific, the analytic structure of analytic structure of bibliometric analysis of thermodynamic research is presented in Fig. 2. The first section dealt with the basic information covering the distribution of languages and annual production. The second section revealed the performance of productive journals and Web of Science categories. Then national contributors countries and institutional contributors institutions were analyzed in the following third and fourth sections. Finally, recent research emphases and trends were examined by the frequency of author keywords.

**Figure 2.** Analytic structure of bibliometric analysis of thermodynamic research

## **2.3. Indicators and acronyms**

The indicators displayed in Fig. 2 for detail analysis are explained in Table 1. As for the section of national and institutional contributors, some newly indicators (CP, SP, FP, and RP) were employed to evaluate the performance of countries/territories and institutions. The institutions' and countries/territories' contributions were identified by the appearance of at least one author in the publications. Collaboration type was determined by the addresses of the authors. The articles were classified by four types for country/territory and institution. (1) The term "single country article" was assigned if the researchers' addresses were from the same country. The term "single institution article" was assigned if the researchers' addresses were from the same institution. (2) The term "internationally collaborative article" was designated to those articles that were coauthored by researchers from multiple countries. The term "inter-institutionally collaborative article" was assigned if authors were from different institution. (3) The term "first author article" was assigned if the first author was from the country/territory or institution for analysis. (4) The term "corresponding author article" was assigned if the corresponding author was from the country/territory or institution for analysis. In addition, the acronyms used in the following analysis were listed in Table 2.

Bibliometric Analysis of Thermodynamic Research: A Science Citation Index Expanded-Based Analysis 523

Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, Russia, the UK, and the USA G8 Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, the UK, and the USA G7 Chinese Academy of Sciences CAS Russian Academy of Sciences RAS Central South University CSU Naval University of Engineering NUE

**Table 2.** Introduction of the acronyms used in subsequent analysis

**Figure 3.** The growth trend of articles in thermodynamic research

of published articles (van Raan, 2005).

calculation of phase diagram CALPHAD

German (146). Some other languages that were less used were as follows: Spanish, Portuguese, Polish, Czech, Korean, Ukrainian, Croatian, Hungarian, Slovak, Serbo-Croatian, and Romanian. The high proportion of English also appears in other research areas, such as 94% of desalination research (Tanaka & Ho, 2011), and 93% in acupuncture research (Han & Ho, 2011). Non-English language publications considerably dilute the the measured impact

Full Name Acronyms


**Table 1.** Explanation of the abbreviations used in subsequent analysis

## **3. Results and discussion**

## **3.1. Language and publication outputs**

There are 41,245 articles with 17 languages used. English which had 38,976 articles (94%) is the most frequently used language in thermodynamic research. The other languages used in more than 100 articles were Russian (863), Chinese (156), French (151), Japanese (147), and


**Table 2.** Introduction of the acronyms used in subsequent analysis

522 Thermodynamics – Fundamentals and Its Application in Science

Abbreviation Indicators

institution, or author keyword)

number of articles

collaborative articles" FP Number of "first author articles"

institutions

**3.1. Language and publication outputs** 

**3. Results and discussion** 

RP Number of "corresponding author articles"

**Table 1.** Explanation of the abbreviations used in subsequent analysis

The indicators displayed in Fig. 2 for detail analysis are explained in Table 1. As for the section of national and institutional contributors, some newly indicators (CP, SP, FP, and RP) were employed to evaluate the performance of countries/territories and institutions. The institutions' and countries/territories' contributions were identified by the appearance of at least one author in the publications. Collaboration type was determined by the addresses of the authors. The articles were classified by four types for country/territory and institution. (1) The term "single country article" was assigned if the researchers' addresses were from the same country. The term "single institution article" was assigned if the researchers' addresses were from the same institution. (2) The term "internationally collaborative article" was designated to those articles that were coauthored by researchers from multiple countries. The term "inter-institutionally collaborative article" was assigned if authors were from different institution. (3) The term "first author article" was assigned if the first author was from the country/territory or institution for analysis. (4) The term "corresponding author article" was assigned if the corresponding author was from the country/territory or institution for analysis. In addition, the acronyms used in the following analysis were listed in Table 2.

TP Number of scientific publications by the analyzed unit (document type,

% Number of papers of an actor (document type, language, journal,

an actor (country/territory or institution) IF Impact factor reported in Journal Citation Reports 2010

%C Number of articles of "internationally collaborative articles" or "inter-

SP Number of "single country articles" or "single institution articles"

R Rankings of number of articles (TP, SP, CP, RP, or FP) by countries or

CP Number of "internationally collaborative articles" or "inter-institutionally

There are 41,245 articles with 17 languages used. English which had 38,976 articles (94%) is the most frequently used language in thermodynamic research. The other languages used in more than 100 articles were Russian (863), Chinese (156), French (151), Japanese (147), and

language, year, journal, Web of Science category, country/territory,

country/territory, institution, or author keyword) as a share of the total

institutionally collaborative articles" as a share of the number of articles of

**2.3. Indicators and acronyms** 

German (146). Some other languages that were less used were as follows: Spanish, Portuguese, Polish, Czech, Korean, Ukrainian, Croatian, Hungarian, Slovak, Serbo-Croatian, and Romanian. The high proportion of English also appears in other research areas, such as 94% of desalination research (Tanaka & Ho, 2011), and 93% in acupuncture research (Han & Ho, 2011). Non-English language publications considerably dilute the the measured impact of published articles (van Raan, 2005).

**Figure 3.** The growth trend of articles in thermodynamic research



Bibliometric Analysis of Thermodynamic Research: A Science Citation Index Expanded-Based Analysis 525

(26/225)

physical chemistry (29/127); multidisciplinary materials science

Journal TP (%) IF Web of Science category (rankings by IF)

Langmuir 242 (0.59) 4.268 multidisciplinary chemistry (24/147);

The thermodynamic research revealed a growth trend through the study period, especially in recent years. The number of articles has been climbing up from 1991 to 2010 in Fig. 3. According to the annual growth rate, it can be divided into two stages: 1991-2003 and 2004- 2010. In the first stage, the growth rate was 48 articles per year from 1,412 in 1991 to 1,988 in 2003, while in the second stage the growth rate has risen four-fold to 203 articles per year

The total articles (41,245) were published in 2,434 sources among 150 Web of Science categories. Table 3 lists the top 20 journals with the greatest number of articles. The impact factors of these journals were also exhibited as reputation of a journal attached much attention by the authors and editors (van Raan, 2001). Approximately 24% of the articles resided in these 20 journals. *Russian Journal of Physical Chemistry A* (IF = 0.523) which was founded in 1930, published the most articles (827; 2.0%). Its former was *Zhurnal fizicheskoi khimii* (1930-1999) and *Russian Journal of Physical Chemistry* (1999-2006)*.* Articles published in this journal concern chemical thermodynamics and thermochemistry (http://www.maik.ru/cgiperl/journal.pl?name=physcha&page=main) which is closely related to the topic of this study. Among the total institutions (1,004) contributing to *Russian Journal of Physical Chemistry A*, 831 institutions (83%) belonged to Russia while only 173 institutions (17%) belonged to other countries. Following three journals: *Journal of Alloys and Compounds* (IF = 2.134), *Physical Review B* (IF = 3.774), and *Journal of Chemical Physics* (IF = 2.920), all had the more than 700 articles. However, the journal which had the highest IF (9.019) was *Journal of the American Chemical Society* in the category of multidisciplinary chemistry which was ranked 17th. *Physical Review Letters* in multidisciplinary physics category was ranked 19th in the list and ranked 2nd in terms of IF (7.621). Furthermore, of these 2,434 sources, 1,828 (75%) sources only contained less than 10 articles; 519 (21%) sources contained 11-100 articles, 60 (2.5%) sources contained 101-200 articles; 20 (0.82%) sources contained 201-600 articles; and seven sources (0.28%) contained more than 600 articles, accounting for 11 percent of the total articles. The trends of the annual publication outputs of the top core seven journals are displayed in Fig. 4. The curves of these seven journals (*Russian Journal of Physical Chemistry A*, *Journal of Alloys and Compounds*, *Physical Review B*, *Journal of Chemical Physics*, *Journal of Chemical Thermodynamics*, and *Thermochimica Acta Biochemistry*) had been interlacing in the study period. However, after 2008, *Journal of Alloys and Compounds* which published 108 articles in 2009 and 70 articles in 2010 showed its domination in the thermodynamic field.

**Table 3.** Characteristics of top 20 journals with the most articles in thermodynamics

from 2,169 in 2004 to 3,410 in 2010.

*3.2.1. Journals* 

**3.2. Journals and Web of Science categories** 


**Table 3.** Characteristics of top 20 journals with the most articles in thermodynamics

The thermodynamic research revealed a growth trend through the study period, especially in recent years. The number of articles has been climbing up from 1991 to 2010 in Fig. 3. According to the annual growth rate, it can be divided into two stages: 1991-2003 and 2004- 2010. In the first stage, the growth rate was 48 articles per year from 1,412 in 1991 to 1,988 in 2003, while in the second stage the growth rate has risen four-fold to 203 articles per year from 2,169 in 2004 to 3,410 in 2010.

## **3.2. Journals and Web of Science categories**

## *3.2.1. Journals*

524 Thermodynamics – Fundamentals and Its Application in Science

Russian Journal of Physical Chemistry A

Compounds

Physics

Journal of Alloys and

Journal of Chemical

Journal of Chemical Thermodynamics

Journal of Physical Chemistry B

CALPHAD-Computer Coupling of Phase Diagrams and Thermochemistry

Journal of Colloid and Interface Science

Journal of Chemical and Engineering Data

Journal of Solution

Journal of Molecular

Journal of the American Chemical Society

Chemistry

Biology

Journal TP (%) IF Web of Science category (rankings by IF)

827 (2.0) 0.503 physical chemistry (114/127)

768 (1.9) 2.134 physical chemistry (63/127);

(7/33)

697 (1.7) 2.794 thermodynamics (3/51); physical chemistry (46/127)

(120/286)

584 (1.4) 3.603 physical chemistry (32/127)

(24/135)

411 (1.0) 3.066 physical chemistry (40/127)

360 (0.87) 1.335 physical chemistry (85/127)

400 (1.0) 2.089 multidisciplinary chemistry (44/147);

matter physics (19/68)

339 (0.82) 4.008 biochemistry & molecular biology (86/286)

& fields physics (5/27)

317 (0.77) 9.019 multidisciplinary chemistry (11/147)

450 (1.1) 1.429 thermodynamics (16/51); physical chemistry (81/127)

mathematical physics (4/54)

chemical engineering (28/135)

Physical Review B 741 (1.8) 3.774 condensed matter physics (13/68)

Thermochimica Acta 652 (1.6) 1.899 analytical chemistry (33/73); physical

Biochemistry 601 (1.5) 3.226 biochemistry & molecular biology

Fluid Phase Equilibria 483 (1.2) 2.253 thermodynamics (5/51); physical

Physical Review E 444 (1.1) 2.352 fluids & plasmas physics (8/31);

Surface Science 382 (0.93) 2.010 physical chemistry (69/127); condensed

Physical Review D 278 (0.67) 4.964 astronomy & astrophysics (8/55); particles

Physical Review Letters 262 (0.64) 7.621 multidisciplinary physics (5/80)

engineering (5/76)

716 (1.7) 2.920 atomic, molecular & chemical physics

chemistry (71/127)

multidisciplinary materials science (50/225); metallurgy & metallurgical

chemistry (61/127); chemical engineering

The total articles (41,245) were published in 2,434 sources among 150 Web of Science categories. Table 3 lists the top 20 journals with the greatest number of articles. The impact factors of these journals were also exhibited as reputation of a journal attached much attention by the authors and editors (van Raan, 2001). Approximately 24% of the articles resided in these 20 journals. *Russian Journal of Physical Chemistry A* (IF = 0.523) which was founded in 1930, published the most articles (827; 2.0%). Its former was *Zhurnal fizicheskoi khimii* (1930-1999) and *Russian Journal of Physical Chemistry* (1999-2006)*.* Articles published in this journal concern chemical thermodynamics and thermochemistry (http://www.maik.ru/cgiperl/journal.pl?name=physcha&page=main) which is closely related to the topic of this study.

Among the total institutions (1,004) contributing to *Russian Journal of Physical Chemistry A*, 831 institutions (83%) belonged to Russia while only 173 institutions (17%) belonged to other countries. Following three journals: *Journal of Alloys and Compounds* (IF = 2.134), *Physical Review B* (IF = 3.774), and *Journal of Chemical Physics* (IF = 2.920), all had the more than 700 articles. However, the journal which had the highest IF (9.019) was *Journal of the American Chemical Society* in the category of multidisciplinary chemistry which was ranked 17th. *Physical Review Letters* in multidisciplinary physics category was ranked 19th in the list and ranked 2nd in terms of IF (7.621). Furthermore, of these 2,434 sources, 1,828 (75%) sources only contained less than 10 articles; 519 (21%) sources contained 11-100 articles, 60 (2.5%) sources contained 101-200 articles; 20 (0.82%) sources contained 201-600 articles; and seven sources (0.28%) contained more than 600 articles, accounting for 11 percent of the total articles. The trends of the annual publication outputs of the top core seven journals are displayed in Fig. 4. The curves of these seven journals (*Russian Journal of Physical Chemistry A*, *Journal of Alloys and Compounds*, *Physical Review B*, *Journal of Chemical Physics*, *Journal of Chemical Thermodynamics*, and *Thermochimica Acta Biochemistry*) had been interlacing in the study period. However, after 2008, *Journal of Alloys and Compounds* which published 108 articles in 2009 and 70 articles in 2010 showed its domination in the thermodynamic field.

Bibliometric Analysis of Thermodynamic Research: A Science Citation Index Expanded-Based Analysis 527

**Figure 5.** The trends of top seven Web of Science categories with more than 3000 articles

Excluding 263 articles without any author address information on the Web of Science, the 40,982 articles originated from 128 countries. Articles originating from England, Scotland, Northern Ireland, and Wales were reclassified as being from the United Kingdom (UK) (Chiu & Ho, 2005). Articles from Hong Kong were included in the ones from China. The geographical global distribution of thermodynamic research is shown in Fig. 6. According to their production, the 128 countries were divided into five parts. Particularly, 81 countries (63%) belonged to the first part of 1-100 articles; 36 countries (28%) belonged to the second part of 101-1,000 articles; seven countries (Japan, France, India, Italy, UK, Spain, and Canada) belonged to the third part of 1,001-3,000 articles; three countries (China, Russia, and Germany) belonged to the fourth part of 3,001-5,000 articles; and only one country (USA) which totally published 9,161 articles, belonged to the fifth part of 5,001-10,000 articles. Although there were only 11 countries which published more than 1,000 articles, these 11 countries produced 77% articles. The majority of articles originated from a small number of particular countries. Furthermore, five continents contributed to the thermodynamics

**3.3. National contributors** 

*3.3.1. Global geographical distribution* 

**Figure 4.** The trends of top seven journals with more than 600 articles

### *3.2.2. Web of Science categories*

As for category analysis, excluding the 84 articles without subject category information, the remained 41,161 articles were analyzed. The most common category was physical chemistry (10,295; 25%), followed distantly by other categories. A half of the above top 20 journals are assigned to the category of physical chemistry. Within the total 150 Web of Science categories, 92 categories (61%) published articles less than 100 articles; 40 categories (27%) published 101-1000 articles; 12 categories (8.0%) published 1,001-3,000 articles; only six categories (4.0%) published more than 3,000 articles. The six core categories including physical chemistry, multidisciplinary materials science, multidisciplinary chemistry, metallurgy & metallurgical engineering, chemical engineering, and biochemistry & molecular biology, took the majority of the total articles with a great percentage of 55%. As illustrated in Fig. 5, these categories showed greater growth rates in recent years than those in 1990s. These trends were similar to the above trends of annual total publication outputs. The articles of position 1st category of physical chemistry which contained 127 journals increased from 390 in 1991 to 777 in 2010. The 2nd position category of multidisciplinary materials science which included 225 journals increased six-fold from 70 in 1991 to 423 in 2010.

**Figure 5.** The trends of top seven Web of Science categories with more than 3000 articles

## **3.3. National contributors**

526 Thermodynamics – Fundamentals and Its Application in Science

**Figure 4.** The trends of top seven journals with more than 600 articles

As for category analysis, excluding the 84 articles without subject category information, the remained 41,161 articles were analyzed. The most common category was physical chemistry (10,295; 25%), followed distantly by other categories. A half of the above top 20 journals are assigned to the category of physical chemistry. Within the total 150 Web of Science categories, 92 categories (61%) published articles less than 100 articles; 40 categories (27%) published 101-1000 articles; 12 categories (8.0%) published 1,001-3,000 articles; only six categories (4.0%) published more than 3,000 articles. The six core categories including physical chemistry, multidisciplinary materials science, multidisciplinary chemistry, metallurgy & metallurgical engineering, chemical engineering, and biochemistry & molecular biology, took the majority of the total articles with a great percentage of 55%. As illustrated in Fig. 5, these categories showed greater growth rates in recent years than those in 1990s. These trends were similar to the above trends of annual total publication outputs. The articles of position 1st category of physical chemistry which contained 127 journals increased from 390 in 1991 to 777 in 2010. The 2nd position category of multidisciplinary materials science which included 225 journals increased six-fold from 70 in 1991 to 423 in

*3.2.2. Web of Science categories* 

2010.

### *3.3.1. Global geographical distribution*

Excluding 263 articles without any author address information on the Web of Science, the 40,982 articles originated from 128 countries. Articles originating from England, Scotland, Northern Ireland, and Wales were reclassified as being from the United Kingdom (UK) (Chiu & Ho, 2005). Articles from Hong Kong were included in the ones from China. The geographical global distribution of thermodynamic research is shown in Fig. 6. According to their production, the 128 countries were divided into five parts. Particularly, 81 countries (63%) belonged to the first part of 1-100 articles; 36 countries (28%) belonged to the second part of 101-1,000 articles; seven countries (Japan, France, India, Italy, UK, Spain, and Canada) belonged to the third part of 1,001-3,000 articles; three countries (China, Russia, and Germany) belonged to the fourth part of 3,001-5,000 articles; and only one country (USA) which totally published 9,161 articles, belonged to the fifth part of 5,001-10,000 articles. Although there were only 11 countries which published more than 1,000 articles, these 11 countries produced 77% articles. The majority of articles originated from a small number of particular countries. Furthermore, five continents contributed to the thermodynamics

research differently. Europe with 42 countries published the most articles 22,969 (56%); Asia with 42 countries published the second most articles 13,163 (32%); and America with sixteen countries published the third most articles 12,333 (30%). Africa, and Oceania two continents made much less contributions, and the quantity of them were 933 (2.3%), and 667 (1.6%), respectively. It is noticeable that Europe is taking the leading position of thermodynamic research. Asia was seeing a striking increase to catch up with Europe in terms of scientific output (Friedberg, 2000; von Bubnoff, 2005).

Bibliometric Analysis of Thermodynamic Research: A Science Citation Index Expanded-Based Analysis 529

Country IN TP TP R (%) SP R (%) CP R (%) FP R (%) RP R (%) %C USA 1,421 9,162 1 (22) 1 (20) 1 (33) 1 (19) 1 (18) 28 China 824 4,652 2 (11) 2 (12) 5 (10) 2 (11) 2 (11) 17 Russia 792 3,792 3 (9.3) 3 (9.1) 6 (10) 3 (8.2) 3 (8.6) 20 Germany 724 3,421 4 (8.3) 6 (5.5) 2 (21) 4 (6.3) 4 (6.2) 47 Japan 580 2,804 5 (6.8) 4 (6.3) 7 (9.0) 5 (5.8) 5 (5.8) 25 France 792 2,515 6 (6.1) 7 (4.1) 3 (15) 7 (4.6) 7 (4.5) 46 India 652 2,201 7 (5.4) 5 (5.7) 15 (3.8) 6 (5.1) 6 (5.0) 13 Italy 390 1,858 8 (4.5) 8 (3.6) 8 (8.6) 8 (3.8) 8 (3.8) 36 UK 315 1,797 9 (4.4) 9 (2.5) 4 (12) 9 (3.0) 9 (2.9) 53 Spain 210 1,487 10 (3.6) 11 (2.5) 9 (8.4) 10 (2.9) 10 (2.8) 44 Canada 192 1,446 11 (3.5) 10 (2.5) 10 (7.8) 11 (2.7) 11 (2.6) 42 Poland 171 934 12 (2.3) 12 (1.6) 11 (5.1) 12 (1.7) 12 (1.7) 42 Netherlands 145 741 13 (1.8) 18 (1.1) 13 (4.7) 17 (1.3) 19 (1.2) 50 Brazil 196 733 14 (1.8) 14 (1.5) 19 (3.1) 13 (1.5) 13 (1.5) 33 Ukraine 229 720 15 (1.8) 15 (1.4) 18 (3.1) 14 (1.4) 14 (1.4) 34 Switzerland 111 690 16 (1.7) 21 (0.93) 12 (4.9) 19 (1.2) 18 (1.2) 55 Sweden 106 645 17 (1.6) 19 (1.1) 16 (3.5) 20 (1.2) 20 (1.1) 42 South Korea 176 632 18 (1.5) 17 (1.3) 22 (2.5) 16 (1.3) 16 (1.4) 31 Iran 173 587 19 (1.4) 13 (1.5) 32 (1.0) 15 (1.4) 15 (1.4) 14 Australia 106 566 20 (1.4) 23 (0.79) 14 (3.9) 21 (1.0) 21 (1.0) 54

Besides, the 9th position UK, the 13th position Netherlands, the 16th position Switzerland, and the 20th position Australia had high cooperation rates no less than 50%. It was also reported that international collaboration in both within and outside the European Communities played an increasing role for European scientific literature (Narin et al., 1991; Glänzel, 1999). South Korea and Iran had higher rankings in terms of FP and RP than that of TP, while Netherlands and Sweden had lower rankings in terms of FP and RP. Moreover, from the above languages analysis, except English, the popular languages (Russian, Chinese, French, Japanese, and German) were just the mother tongue of the top five countries China, Russia, Germany, Japan, and France except the USA. The excellent performance of these countries

The comparison of top six countries with the most articles in 2010 is illustrated in Fig. 7. The USA hold the trump card based on the total number of articles in the study period, but did not have the highest growth rate. China which was ranked 1st according to the 2010 production had the highest growth rate of 32 articles per year, and surpassed the USA in 2009, following distantly by other countries. USA, India, and Russia had the lower growth

IN: Number of institutions.

**Table 4.** Characteristics of the top 20 productive countries/territories

was consistent with the results of language analysis.

*3.3.3. Comparison of top six countries* 

**Figure 6.** Global geographical distribution of thermodynamics research outputs

## *3.3.2. Characteristics of top 20 countries/territories*

With respect to international collaboration, 33,234 (81%) were independent publications and 7,748 (19%) were internationally collaborative publications. The collaboration rate was a little greater than that of other areas, such as 14% biosorption technology for water treatment (Ho, 2008), 16% of desalination research (Tanaka & Ho, 2011), 16% of solid waste research (Fu et al., 2010), and 14% of acupuncture research (Han & Ho, 2011). Table 4 shows the characteristics of the top 20 productive countries. The eight major industrialized countries G8, ranked in the top 11 in Table 4, had 59% over the investigation period. Similarly, the seven major industrialized countries G7 the USA, Germany, the UK, Japan, France, Canada, and Italy accounted for a significant proportion exited in many researches (Li et al., 2009; He, 2009; Fu et al., 2010; Wang et al., 2010). The USA dominated, ranking 1st in independent and collaborative articles, as well as first author and corresponding author articles. Total 1,421 contributing institutions (13%) were affiliated with USA, followed by China (824 institutions, 7.7%), and Russia (792 institutions, 6.5%). The 2nd position China, the 7th position India, and the 19th position Iran had low percentages of collaboration less than 20%. It was not coincident that China emerged as a leading nation in science production (Zhou & Leydesdorff, 2006; Zhou & Leydesdorff, 2008). In most fields, the USA had the quantity (number of papers) lead, although the China has made dramatic strides to overtake the USA, except the biomedical field and some aspects of environmental science (Kostoff, 2008).


IN: Number of institutions.

528 Thermodynamics – Fundamentals and Its Application in Science

output (Friedberg, 2000; von Bubnoff, 2005).

**Figure 6.** Global geographical distribution of thermodynamics research outputs

With respect to international collaboration, 33,234 (81%) were independent publications and 7,748 (19%) were internationally collaborative publications. The collaboration rate was a little greater than that of other areas, such as 14% biosorption technology for water treatment (Ho, 2008), 16% of desalination research (Tanaka & Ho, 2011), 16% of solid waste research (Fu et al., 2010), and 14% of acupuncture research (Han & Ho, 2011). Table 4 shows the characteristics of the top 20 productive countries. The eight major industrialized countries G8, ranked in the top 11 in Table 4, had 59% over the investigation period. Similarly, the seven major industrialized countries G7 the USA, Germany, the UK, Japan, France, Canada, and Italy accounted for a significant proportion exited in many researches (Li et al., 2009; He, 2009; Fu et al., 2010; Wang et al., 2010). The USA dominated, ranking 1st in independent and collaborative articles, as well as first author and corresponding author articles. Total 1,421 contributing institutions (13%) were affiliated with USA, followed by China (824 institutions, 7.7%), and Russia (792 institutions, 6.5%). The 2nd position China, the 7th position India, and the 19th position Iran had low percentages of collaboration less than 20%. It was not coincident that China emerged as a leading nation in science production (Zhou & Leydesdorff, 2006; Zhou & Leydesdorff, 2008). In most fields, the USA had the quantity (number of papers) lead, although the China has made dramatic strides to overtake the USA,

except the biomedical field and some aspects of environmental science (Kostoff, 2008).

*3.3.2. Characteristics of top 20 countries/territories* 

research differently. Europe with 42 countries published the most articles 22,969 (56%); Asia with 42 countries published the second most articles 13,163 (32%); and America with sixteen countries published the third most articles 12,333 (30%). Africa, and Oceania two continents made much less contributions, and the quantity of them were 933 (2.3%), and 667 (1.6%), respectively. It is noticeable that Europe is taking the leading position of thermodynamic research. Asia was seeing a striking increase to catch up with Europe in terms of scientific

**Table 4.** Characteristics of the top 20 productive countries/territories

Besides, the 9th position UK, the 13th position Netherlands, the 16th position Switzerland, and the 20th position Australia had high cooperation rates no less than 50%. It was also reported that international collaboration in both within and outside the European Communities played an increasing role for European scientific literature (Narin et al., 1991; Glänzel, 1999). South Korea and Iran had higher rankings in terms of FP and RP than that of TP, while Netherlands and Sweden had lower rankings in terms of FP and RP. Moreover, from the above languages analysis, except English, the popular languages (Russian, Chinese, French, Japanese, and German) were just the mother tongue of the top five countries China, Russia, Germany, Japan, and France except the USA. The excellent performance of these countries was consistent with the results of language analysis.

## *3.3.3. Comparison of top six countries*

The comparison of top six countries with the most articles in 2010 is illustrated in Fig. 7. The USA hold the trump card based on the total number of articles in the study period, but did not have the highest growth rate. China which was ranked 1st according to the 2010 production had the highest growth rate of 32 articles per year, and surpassed the USA in 2009, following distantly by other countries. USA, India, and Russia had the lower growth rate of 10 - 13 articles per year. The following Germany and France had the growth rate of 6.3 and 5.9 articles per year. Particularly, Russia experienced a sharply increase in the first three year from 6 articles in 1991 to 174 articles in 1993, may due to its large fund for recovery of the politic reason (Goodman, 1993; Webb, 1994). The Russian annual output grew from 1980 to 1990, but fell after the dissolution of the USSR in late 1991; from 1994 there has been an inconsistent partial recovery, and by 2000 the annual output had approximately regained its 1980 value (Wilson & Markusova, 2004). It seems that the recovery time of Russian thermodynamic research was shorter.

Bibliometric Analysis of Thermodynamic Research: A Science Citation Index Expanded-Based Analysis 531

of 1993, the annual CPP of China fluctuated ranging 6.2-11 in 1991-2006, and decreased after 2007 down to 1.9 in 2010. Both countries indicated declines as for annual CPPs, which can be attributed to that it needs time to accumulate their citations (Picknett & Davis, 1999). The outstanding performance of China's CPP in 1993 might be owned to the two highly cited articles of a series by the same authors. They were "thermodynamics of molecular recognition by cyclodextrins. 1. calorimetric titration of inclusion complexation of naphthalenesulfonates with -, -, and -cyclodextrin: enthalpy entropy compensation" (Inoue et al., 1993a) with 344 citations and "thermodynamics of molecular recognition by cyclodextrins. calorimetric titration of inclusion complexation with modified -cyclodextrins. enthalpy-entropy compensation in host-guest complexation: from ionophore to cyclodextrin and cyclophane"(Inoue et al., 1993b) with 198 citations, respectively. Furthermore, the most frequently cited article was "a modified UNIFAC model. 2. present parameter matrix and results for different thermodynamic properties" (Gmehling et al., 1993) with 727 citations. Although this article was published by authors from Germany only, it was also assigned to China according to its address record from Web of Science, because one of the authors had permanent address of China. It is a bias of address information for articles from Web of Science. China's CPP in 1993 were still high (CPP = 20) without these highest citations articles. Likewise, the well performance of the USA's CPP in 1991 can be ascribed to the top cited article "protein folding and association: insights from the interfacial and thermodynamic

**Figure 8.** Comparison of USA and China by number of articles and citations per publication

**Figure 7.** Trends of top six countries with most articles in 2010

#### *3.3.4. Comparison of China and USA*

In order to compare the most productive country in 1991-2010, the USA and the most active country in 2010, China, annual number of articles and citations per publication (CPP) of both were presented in Fig. 8. Total citations were collected on November 20 in 2011 from web of Science. From the above analysis, China experienced a high grow rate and got ahead of the USA in 2009 and kept on top in 2010. However, in terms of CPP, the mean number of China was 7.1 which was much less than that of the USA (23). The annual CPP of the USA showed a declined trend in 1991-2010, ranging from 53 in 1991 to 2.8 in 2010. Except the year

recovery time of Russian thermodynamic research was shorter.

**Figure 7.** Trends of top six countries with most articles in 2010

In order to compare the most productive country in 1991-2010, the USA and the most active country in 2010, China, annual number of articles and citations per publication (CPP) of both were presented in Fig. 8. Total citations were collected on November 20 in 2011 from web of Science. From the above analysis, China experienced a high grow rate and got ahead of the USA in 2009 and kept on top in 2010. However, in terms of CPP, the mean number of China was 7.1 which was much less than that of the USA (23). The annual CPP of the USA showed a declined trend in 1991-2010, ranging from 53 in 1991 to 2.8 in 2010. Except the year

*3.3.4. Comparison of China and USA* 

rate of 10 - 13 articles per year. The following Germany and France had the growth rate of 6.3 and 5.9 articles per year. Particularly, Russia experienced a sharply increase in the first three year from 6 articles in 1991 to 174 articles in 1993, may due to its large fund for recovery of the politic reason (Goodman, 1993; Webb, 1994). The Russian annual output grew from 1980 to 1990, but fell after the dissolution of the USSR in late 1991; from 1994 there has been an inconsistent partial recovery, and by 2000 the annual output had approximately regained its 1980 value (Wilson & Markusova, 2004). It seems that the of 1993, the annual CPP of China fluctuated ranging 6.2-11 in 1991-2006, and decreased after 2007 down to 1.9 in 2010. Both countries indicated declines as for annual CPPs, which can be attributed to that it needs time to accumulate their citations (Picknett & Davis, 1999). The outstanding performance of China's CPP in 1993 might be owned to the two highly cited articles of a series by the same authors. They were "thermodynamics of molecular recognition by cyclodextrins. 1. calorimetric titration of inclusion complexation of naphthalenesulfonates with -, -, and -cyclodextrin: enthalpy entropy compensation" (Inoue et al., 1993a) with 344 citations and "thermodynamics of molecular recognition by cyclodextrins. calorimetric titration of inclusion complexation with modified -cyclodextrins. enthalpy-entropy compensation in host-guest complexation: from ionophore to cyclodextrin and cyclophane"(Inoue et al., 1993b) with 198 citations, respectively. Furthermore, the most frequently cited article was "a modified UNIFAC model. 2. present parameter matrix and results for different thermodynamic properties" (Gmehling et al., 1993) with 727 citations. Although this article was published by authors from Germany only, it was also assigned to China according to its address record from Web of Science, because one of the authors had permanent address of China. It is a bias of address information for articles from Web of Science. China's CPP in 1993 were still high (CPP = 20) without these highest citations articles. Likewise, the well performance of the USA's CPP in 1991 can be ascribed to the top cited article "protein folding and association: insights from the interfacial and thermodynamic

**Figure 8.** Comparison of USA and China by number of articles and citations per publication

properties of hydrocarbons" which was published in 1991 (Nicholls et al., 1991) and received 4,999 citations. Most scientific publications from China have a lower citation impact than the world average and have a lower citation rate than expected (Glänzel et al., 2002). It is suggested that China's science needs to move from the "quantitative expansion" phase in nowadays to a "rising quality" phase (Jin & Rousseau, 2005). In general, China showed a high growth rate in recent years and dominant now in annual production, but still needs to make efforts on increasing their citations in thermodynamics.

Bibliometric Analysis of Thermodynamic Research: A Science Citation Index Expanded-Based Analysis 533

SP R (%)

CP R (%)

425 3 (1.0) 2 (0.93) 5 (1.2) 3 (0.75) 3 (0.80) 47

313 5 (0.76) 23 (0.34) 3 (1.4) 11 (0.41) 13 (0.39) 73

265 7 (0.65) 9 (0.53) 14 (0.82) 5 (0.47) 5 (0.48) 52

222 15 (0.54) 8 (0.55) 35 (0.53) 10 (0.42) 11 (0.40) 40

201 19 (0.49) 7 (0.57) 80 (0.37) 12 (0.41) 9 (0.43) 31

6 (1.1) 52 (0.20) 58 (0.19) 87

(0.11)

FP R (%)

RP R (%)

% C

(%)

Russian Academy of Sciences, Russia 1,604 1 (3.9) 1 (3.7) 1 (4.2) 1 (3.0) 1 (3.1) 43 Chinese Academy of Sciences, China 720 2 (1.8) 3 (0.92) 2 (3.0) 2 (1.1) 2 (1.1) 69

Tohoku University, Japan 335 4 (0.82) 10 (0.52) 4 (1.3) 8 (0.46) 7 (0.45) 62

University of Tokyo, Japan 280 6 (0.68) 6 (0.57) 11 (0.84) 6 (0.46) 6 (0.45) 50

Royal Institute of Technology, Sweden 261 8 (0.64) 14 (0.45) 7 (0.91) 12 (0.41) 11 (0.40) 58 Pennsylvania State University, USA 256 9 (0.62) 5 (0.58) 19 (0.69) 9 (0.45) 10 (0.43) 45 Central South University, China 247 10 (0.60) 11 (0.51) 18 (0.74) 4 (0.50) 4 (0.52) 50 University of Wisconsin-Madison, USA 245 11 (0.60) 14 (0.45) 15 (0.81) 14 (0.41) 18 (0.37) 55 Indian Institute of Technology, India 242 12 (0.59) 4 (0.67) 42 (0.48) 6 (0.46) 8 (0.44) 33 University of California, USA 241 13 (0.59) 18 (0.39) 8 (0.88) 16 (0.39) 22 (0.33) 61 Osaka University, Japan 240 14 (0.59) 16 (0.41) 11 (0.84) 17 (0.37) 15 (0.38) 58

University of Cambridge, UK 220 16 (0.54) 29 (0.30) 8 (0.88) 22 (0.34) 24 (0.33) 66 Polish Academy of Sciences, Poland 219 17 (0.53) 24 (0.33) 13 (0.83) 22 (0.34) 21 (0.35) 63

Kyoto University, Japan 200 20 (0.49) 18 (0.39) 27 (0.63) 18 (0.36) 17 (0.37) 53

More independent institutions might lead to more first author articles and corresponding author articles or vice versa. Some institutions which had low collaboration rates no more than 40% usually had a higher rank in FP and RP. For example, the 12th place Indian Institute of Technology in India with the low collaboration rate of 33% ranked 6th in FP and 8th in RP; the 15th position Massachusetts Institute of Technology in USA with the low collaboration rate of 40% ranked 10th in FP and 11th in RP; the 19th position National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine in Ukraine with the low collaboration rate of 31% ranked 12th in FP and 9th in RP. On the other hand, some institutions which had high collaboration rates more than 70% were ranked lower in the rankings of FP and RP. For example, the 5th position Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique in France with the high collaboration rate of 73% ranked 11th in FP and 13th in RP; the 18th position National Research Council in

Italy with the high collaboration rate of 87% ranked 52th in FP and 58th in RP.

Institution TP TP R

Moscow Lomonosov State University,

University of Science and Technology

Massachusetts Institute of Technology,

National Academy of Sciences of

Ukraine, Ukraine

National Research Council, Italy 208 18 (0.51) 166

**Table 5.** Characteristics of the top 20 productive institutions.

Centre National de la Recherche

Scientifique, France

Beijing, China

USA

Russia

## **3.4. Institutional contributors**

## *3.4.1. Characteristics of top 20 institutions*

After examining the national contributors, the characteristics of institutional contributors institutions were identified. Of 40,982 articles from 10,696 institutions in 128 countries, 16,628 (41%) were inter-institutionally collaborative publications, and 24,354 (59%) were independent publications. The percentage of collaboration among institutions was much higher than that among countries (19%). The inter-institutional collaboration rate was usually greater than international collaboration rates (Fu et al., 2010; Han & Ho, 2011; Li et al., 2011; Tanaka &Ho, 2011). The number of articles of institutions was smaller than the country, and it was reported that the collaboration was more likely to happen when the size of actors was small (Narin et al., 1991). Nevertheless, the inter-institutional collaboration rate (41%) of thermodynamic research was observed to be lower than that of many other fields, such as 62% of global climate change (Li et al., 2011), 53% in atmospheric simulation (Li et al., 2009), 44% in solid waste research (Fu et al., 2010), and 53% of acupuncture research (Han &Ho, 2011). Four institutions in the USA and Japan, three in China, two each in Russia, and one each in Sweden, Ukraine, UK, India, France, and Italy were ranked in the top 20 productive institutions (16%) as shown in Table 5. It is worth noting that the Russian Academy of Sciences ranked 1st and Chinese Academy of Sciences ranked 2nd are both integrated research centers and made up of many relatively independent institutions distributed throughout their country. At present, the publications of these institutions were pooled as one heading, and publications divided into branches would result in different rankings. A bias appeared because national research institutions might have many branches in different cities, for example the CAS (Li et al., 2009), the RAS (Li et al., 2009), and Indian Institute of Technology (Tanaka & Ho, 2011). RAS founded the most productive thermodynamic journal of *Russian Journal of Physical Chemistry A*. In particular, 228 articles (28%) were contributed by RAS, and 117 articles (14%) were contributed by Moscow Lomonosov State University in Russia based on the total articles (817 articles with author information) of *Russian Journal of Physical Chemistry A* during 1991-2010. With the exception of these two institutions, the most productive institution is Moscow Lomonosov State University in Russia (425; 1.0%), followed by Tohoku University in Japan (335; 0.82%), and Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique in France (313; 0.76%). However, a bias would appear in the analysis of institutions which was used by different names in their publications. It is strongly recommended that an "international identity number" for all institutions when authors published their paper with an institution as affiliation in a Web of Science-listed journal (Chiu &Ho, 2007).


Bibliometric Analysis of Thermodynamic Research: A Science Citation Index Expanded-Based Analysis 533

**Table 5.** Characteristics of the top 20 productive institutions.

532 Thermodynamics – Fundamentals and Its Application in Science

**3.4. Institutional contributors** 

*3.4.1. Characteristics of top 20 institutions* 

Science-listed journal (Chiu &Ho, 2007).

make efforts on increasing their citations in thermodynamics.

properties of hydrocarbons" which was published in 1991 (Nicholls et al., 1991) and received 4,999 citations. Most scientific publications from China have a lower citation impact than the world average and have a lower citation rate than expected (Glänzel et al., 2002). It is suggested that China's science needs to move from the "quantitative expansion" phase in nowadays to a "rising quality" phase (Jin & Rousseau, 2005). In general, China showed a high growth rate in recent years and dominant now in annual production, but still needs to

After examining the national contributors, the characteristics of institutional contributors institutions were identified. Of 40,982 articles from 10,696 institutions in 128 countries, 16,628 (41%) were inter-institutionally collaborative publications, and 24,354 (59%) were independent publications. The percentage of collaboration among institutions was much higher than that among countries (19%). The inter-institutional collaboration rate was usually greater than international collaboration rates (Fu et al., 2010; Han & Ho, 2011; Li et al., 2011; Tanaka &Ho, 2011). The number of articles of institutions was smaller than the country, and it was reported that the collaboration was more likely to happen when the size of actors was small (Narin et al., 1991). Nevertheless, the inter-institutional collaboration rate (41%) of thermodynamic research was observed to be lower than that of many other fields, such as 62% of global climate change (Li et al., 2011), 53% in atmospheric simulation (Li et al., 2009), 44% in solid waste research (Fu et al., 2010), and 53% of acupuncture research (Han &Ho, 2011). Four institutions in the USA and Japan, three in China, two each in Russia, and one each in Sweden, Ukraine, UK, India, France, and Italy were ranked in the top 20 productive institutions (16%) as shown in Table 5. It is worth noting that the Russian Academy of Sciences ranked 1st and Chinese Academy of Sciences ranked 2nd are both integrated research centers and made up of many relatively independent institutions distributed throughout their country. At present, the publications of these institutions were pooled as one heading, and publications divided into branches would result in different rankings. A bias appeared because national research institutions might have many branches in different cities, for example the CAS (Li et al., 2009), the RAS (Li et al., 2009), and Indian Institute of Technology (Tanaka & Ho, 2011). RAS founded the most productive thermodynamic journal of *Russian Journal of Physical Chemistry A*. In particular, 228 articles (28%) were contributed by RAS, and 117 articles (14%) were contributed by Moscow Lomonosov State University in Russia based on the total articles (817 articles with author information) of *Russian Journal of Physical Chemistry A* during 1991-2010. With the exception of these two institutions, the most productive institution is Moscow Lomonosov State University in Russia (425; 1.0%), followed by Tohoku University in Japan (335; 0.82%), and Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique in France (313; 0.76%). However, a bias would appear in the analysis of institutions which was used by different names in their publications. It is strongly recommended that an "international identity number" for all institutions when authors published their paper with an institution as affiliation in a Web of

More independent institutions might lead to more first author articles and corresponding author articles or vice versa. Some institutions which had low collaboration rates no more than 40% usually had a higher rank in FP and RP. For example, the 12th place Indian Institute of Technology in India with the low collaboration rate of 33% ranked 6th in FP and 8th in RP; the 15th position Massachusetts Institute of Technology in USA with the low collaboration rate of 40% ranked 10th in FP and 11th in RP; the 19th position National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine in Ukraine with the low collaboration rate of 31% ranked 12th in FP and 9th in RP. On the other hand, some institutions which had high collaboration rates more than 70% were ranked lower in the rankings of FP and RP. For example, the 5th position Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique in France with the high collaboration rate of 73% ranked 11th in FP and 13th in RP; the 18th position National Research Council in Italy with the high collaboration rate of 87% ranked 52th in FP and 58th in RP.

#### *3.4.2. Comparison of top seven institutions*

To identify the growth trends of active institutions in recent years, the trends of top seven productive institutions with most articles in 2010 are shown in Fig. 9. The most productive institution - RAS had an overwhelming majority in the total articles, and CAS was just down by three articles in 2010, following distantly by the other institutions. CAS as the China's highest academic institution in natural sciences played an active role in terms of scientific outputs in recent years as the exponentially growth scientific production in China (Li et al., 2009; Fu et al., 2010; Tanaka &Ho, 2011; Fu et al., 2011; Li et al., 2011).

Bibliometric Analysis of Thermodynamic Research: A Science Citation Index Expanded-Based Analysis 535

per year. About 14% percent articles in RAS were published in *Russian Journal of Physical Chemistry A* which was founded by RAS. It was interesting that the top three institutions (CAS, CSU, and NUE) with the greatest growth rates were all in China. CSU was established in 2000 by merging three separate universities: Hunan Medical University, Changsha Railway University, and Central South University of technology, and was involved in "985 Project" and "211 Project" which were supported by Chinese government to promote the development and reputation of the Chinese higher education system (http://iecd.csu.edu.cn/en-US/ColumnS.aspx?cid=12). Moreover, CSU hold one SCI journal named *Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China* which published 11% thermodynamic related articles of CSU in the study period. Another institution, NUE ranks as a military university of higher learning subjected to the leadership of the Central Military Commission and the Party Committee of the PLA Navy, and is listed as one of the five comprehensive universities in the armed forces and the army "2110 project" that enjoys the priority in development. It falls into the category of key national university specializing in engineering

(http://english.chinamil.com.cn/site2/special-reports/2007-06/21/content\_853791.htm).

Bibliometric analysis of author keywords has been only observed in recent years (Chiu &Ho, 2007; Wang et al., 2010; Li et al., 2011). It tried to find the research emphases and trends by quantitatively analyzing the frequency of author keywords. Excluding some articles without author keywords information, 23,458 articles (57%) with records of author keywords in the SCI-Expanded database were analyzed. There were 45,182 author keywords listed by authors, 43,930 (97%) keywords were used no more than ten times, which indicated that thermodynamic research involved diverse scientific literature and a wide disparity in research focuses (Chuang et al., 2007). Only 74 (0.16%) author keywords were used no less than 100 times, suggesting that the mainstream research in thermodynamics was considered to focus on a small field. Four five-year intervals (1991- 1995, 1996-2000, 2001-2005, and 2006-2010) were employed to obtain the trends of these author keywords as well as minimize the year-to-year fluctuations. The top 30 author keywords (accounting for 37% of the total articles) in the latest interval 2006-2010 are listed

Except the author keywords "thermodynamics", "thermodynamic properties", "thermodynamic parameters", and "thermodynamic" related to searching keywords, the three most frequently used author keywords were "kinetics" (883; 3.8%), "adsorption" (736; 3.1%), and "phase diagram" (545; 2.3%). "Thermodynamics" and "kinetics" were related to one another in ways, and were both commonly used to describe process (Kocks et al., 1975; Astumian, 1997; Ho & Ofomaja, 2005). "Adsorption" was a widely applied process, for example in environmental science (Wang et al., 2010; Wang et al., 2011; Chuang et al., 2011). The term "phase diagram" is a type of chart used to obtaining thermodynamic data at

**3.5. Research emphases and trends** 

equilibrium (Kleppa, 1952; Svirbely, 1954).

in Table 6.

**Figure 9.** Trends of top seven institutions with most articles in 2010

Although three universities in China including Central South University, Naval University of Engineering, and SiChuan University just ranked 10th, 39th, and 43rd of total articles from 1991 to 2010, but they had high rankings (3rd, 4th, and 7th) with respect to the number of articles in 2010. The growth rates of the top institutions differed from each other. Particularly, based on the last decade (2001-2010), CAS showed the highest growth rate of 7.2 articles per year; CSU and NUE showed the growth rate of 4 – 5 articles per year. The other four institutions, RAS, Moscow Lomonosov State University, University of Science and Technology Beijing, and SiChuan University showed the growth rate of 1 – 2 articles per year. About 14% percent articles in RAS were published in *Russian Journal of Physical Chemistry A* which was founded by RAS. It was interesting that the top three institutions (CAS, CSU, and NUE) with the greatest growth rates were all in China. CSU was established in 2000 by merging three separate universities: Hunan Medical University, Changsha Railway University, and Central South University of technology, and was involved in "985 Project" and "211 Project" which were supported by Chinese government to promote the development and reputation of the Chinese higher education system (http://iecd.csu.edu.cn/en-US/ColumnS.aspx?cid=12). Moreover, CSU hold one SCI journal named *Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China* which published 11% thermodynamic related articles of CSU in the study period. Another institution, NUE ranks as a military university of higher learning subjected to the leadership of the Central Military Commission and the Party Committee of the PLA Navy, and is listed as one of the five comprehensive universities in the armed forces and the army "2110 project" that enjoys the priority in development. It falls into the category of key national university specializing in engineering (http://english.chinamil.com.cn/site2/special-reports/2007-06/21/content\_853791.htm).

## **3.5. Research emphases and trends**

534 Thermodynamics – Fundamentals and Its Application in Science

To identify the growth trends of active institutions in recent years, the trends of top seven productive institutions with most articles in 2010 are shown in Fig. 9. The most productive institution - RAS had an overwhelming majority in the total articles, and CAS was just down by three articles in 2010, following distantly by the other institutions. CAS as the China's highest academic institution in natural sciences played an active role in terms of scientific outputs in recent years as the exponentially growth scientific production in China (Li et al.,

2009; Fu et al., 2010; Tanaka &Ho, 2011; Fu et al., 2011; Li et al., 2011).

**Figure 9.** Trends of top seven institutions with most articles in 2010

Although three universities in China including Central South University, Naval University of Engineering, and SiChuan University just ranked 10th, 39th, and 43rd of total articles from 1991 to 2010, but they had high rankings (3rd, 4th, and 7th) with respect to the number of articles in 2010. The growth rates of the top institutions differed from each other. Particularly, based on the last decade (2001-2010), CAS showed the highest growth rate of 7.2 articles per year; CSU and NUE showed the growth rate of 4 – 5 articles per year. The other four institutions, RAS, Moscow Lomonosov State University, University of Science and Technology Beijing, and SiChuan University showed the growth rate of 1 – 2 articles

*3.4.2. Comparison of top seven institutions* 

Bibliometric analysis of author keywords has been only observed in recent years (Chiu &Ho, 2007; Wang et al., 2010; Li et al., 2011). It tried to find the research emphases and trends by quantitatively analyzing the frequency of author keywords. Excluding some articles without author keywords information, 23,458 articles (57%) with records of author keywords in the SCI-Expanded database were analyzed. There were 45,182 author keywords listed by authors, 43,930 (97%) keywords were used no more than ten times, which indicated that thermodynamic research involved diverse scientific literature and a wide disparity in research focuses (Chuang et al., 2007). Only 74 (0.16%) author keywords were used no less than 100 times, suggesting that the mainstream research in thermodynamics was considered to focus on a small field. Four five-year intervals (1991- 1995, 1996-2000, 2001-2005, and 2006-2010) were employed to obtain the trends of these author keywords as well as minimize the year-to-year fluctuations. The top 30 author keywords (accounting for 37% of the total articles) in the latest interval 2006-2010 are listed in Table 6.

Except the author keywords "thermodynamics", "thermodynamic properties", "thermodynamic parameters", and "thermodynamic" related to searching keywords, the three most frequently used author keywords were "kinetics" (883; 3.8%), "adsorption" (736; 3.1%), and "phase diagram" (545; 2.3%). "Thermodynamics" and "kinetics" were related to one another in ways, and were both commonly used to describe process (Kocks et al., 1975; Astumian, 1997; Ho & Ofomaja, 2005). "Adsorption" was a widely applied process, for example in environmental science (Wang et al., 2010; Wang et al., 2011; Chuang et al., 2011). The term "phase diagram" is a type of chart used to obtaining thermodynamic data at equilibrium (Kleppa, 1952; Svirbely, 1954).


Bibliometric Analysis of Thermodynamic Research: A Science Citation Index Expanded-Based Analysis 537

In particular, there were also some emerging hotspots in thermodynamics recently. Some author keywords including the 3rd "adsorption", the 9th "thermodynamic modeling", the 14th "CALPHAD", the 17th "thermodynamic property", the 18th "density functional theory", the 19th "isothermal titration calorimetry", the 20th "thermodynamic stability", the 21st "isotherm", the 25th "free energy", the 27th "biosorption", and the 28th "AB initio calculations" in the list showed the increasing trends during the study period. It is noticeable that "CALPHAD", "biosorption", and "AB initio calculations" increased rapidly from zero articles in 1991-1995 into the top 30 rankings in 2006-2010. "CALPHAD" was firstly used as the author keyword of the article entitled "compilation of 'CALPHAD' formation enthalpy data - Binary intermetallic compounds in the COST507 Gibbsian database" in 1998 (Fries & Jantzen, 1998). However, "CALPHAD method" had been used as the author keyword of the article titled "thermodynamic study on the Ag-Sb-Sn system" in 1996 (Oh et al., 1996). The first article which employed "biosorption" as author keyword was titled "determination of the equilibrium, kinetic and thermodynamic parameters of the batch biosorption of nickel(II) ions onto Chlorella vulgaris" in *Process Biochemistry* in 2002 (Aksu, 2002). "Biosorption" as a process for water treatment received increasing attention in recent years (Ho, 2008). As for "AB initio calculations", it was originally utilized as author keywords of the article "an AB initio study of structures and energetics of copper sulfide clusters" in 1996 (Dehnen et al., 1996). Similarly, "density functional theory", "isothermal titration calorimetry", and "isotherm" grew fast from the 1288th (only one article) in 1991- 1995 to 18th, 19th, and 21st in 2006-2010. The article targeting at "density functional theory" could be found in 1994 and it was entitled "density-functional theory as thermodynamics" (Nagy & Parr, 1994). Thermodynamical interpretation of the density functional theory for an electronic ground state was developed (Nagy & Parr, 1994). The following article which utilized "density functional theory" as author keyword was published in 1999. For the phrase "isothermal titration calorimetry", the article which used it as author keyword appeared in 1995, and it was titled "comparative thermodynamic analyses of the Fv, Fab\* and Fab fragments of anti-dansyl mouse monoclonal-antibody" (Shimba, 1995). However, it should be noticed that there was a bias that all these analysis were based on the data (57%)

Except the dominant language English, Russian, Chinese, French, Japanese and German were the most common languages. Above all, the growth process of annual thermodynamic scientific outputs can be divided into two stages, and the annual growth rate of the second stage 2004-2010 was four times of that in the first stage 1991-2003. Secondly, *Russian Journal of Physical Chemistry* was the most productive journal, and then *Journal of Alloys and Compounds and Journal of Chemical Physics*. The most common category was found to be physical chemistry. Thirdly, the global geographic distribution discovered that Europe took the leading position, following by Asia, America, Africa and Oceania. In particular, the eight major industrialized countries (G8: Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, Russia, the UK, and USA) played a prominent role with more than a half contribution, especially the USA.

with author keywords information from SCI-Expanded.

**4. Conclusion** 

N/A: Not Available

**Table 6.** The most frequently used 30 author keywords in 2006-2010

In particular, there were also some emerging hotspots in thermodynamics recently. Some author keywords including the 3rd "adsorption", the 9th "thermodynamic modeling", the 14th "CALPHAD", the 17th "thermodynamic property", the 18th "density functional theory", the 19th "isothermal titration calorimetry", the 20th "thermodynamic stability", the 21st "isotherm", the 25th "free energy", the 27th "biosorption", and the 28th "AB initio calculations" in the list showed the increasing trends during the study period. It is noticeable that "CALPHAD", "biosorption", and "AB initio calculations" increased rapidly from zero articles in 1991-1995 into the top 30 rankings in 2006-2010. "CALPHAD" was firstly used as the author keyword of the article entitled "compilation of 'CALPHAD' formation enthalpy data - Binary intermetallic compounds in the COST507 Gibbsian database" in 1998 (Fries & Jantzen, 1998). However, "CALPHAD method" had been used as the author keyword of the article titled "thermodynamic study on the Ag-Sb-Sn system" in 1996 (Oh et al., 1996). The first article which employed "biosorption" as author keyword was titled "determination of the equilibrium, kinetic and thermodynamic parameters of the batch biosorption of nickel(II) ions onto Chlorella vulgaris" in *Process Biochemistry* in 2002 (Aksu, 2002). "Biosorption" as a process for water treatment received increasing attention in recent years (Ho, 2008). As for "AB initio calculations", it was originally utilized as author keywords of the article "an AB initio study of structures and energetics of copper sulfide clusters" in 1996 (Dehnen et al., 1996). Similarly, "density functional theory", "isothermal titration calorimetry", and "isotherm" grew fast from the 1288th (only one article) in 1991- 1995 to 18th, 19th, and 21st in 2006-2010. The article targeting at "density functional theory" could be found in 1994 and it was entitled "density-functional theory as thermodynamics" (Nagy & Parr, 1994). Thermodynamical interpretation of the density functional theory for an electronic ground state was developed (Nagy & Parr, 1994). The following article which utilized "density functional theory" as author keyword was published in 1999. For the phrase "isothermal titration calorimetry", the article which used it as author keyword appeared in 1995, and it was titled "comparative thermodynamic analyses of the Fv, Fab\* and Fab fragments of anti-dansyl mouse monoclonal-antibody" (Shimba, 1995). However, it should be noticed that there was a bias that all these analysis were based on the data (57%) with author keywords information from SCI-Expanded.

## **4. Conclusion**

536 Thermodynamics – Fundamentals and Its Application in Science

R (%)

1991-1995 R (%)

1,577 2 (6.7) 2 (5.5) 2 (8.4) 2 (5.9) 2 (6.7)

778 4 (3.3) 3 (2.6) 3 (3.5) 4 (3.2) 5 (3.5)

338 13 (1.4) 165 (0.27) 56 (0.50) 16 (1.3) 9 (2.2)

385 11 (1.6) 12 (1.5) 14 (1.7) 12 (1.3) 10 (1.8)

212 20 (0.90) 59 (0.59) 64 (0.45) 25 (0.83) 17 (1.2)

158 36 (0.67) 1288 (0.045) 415 (0.11) 56 (0.53) 18 (1.1)

177 28 (0.75) 1288 (0.045) 108 (0.34) 31 (0.70) 19 (1.1)

265 16 (1.1) 38 (0.77) 16 (1.3) 13 (1.3) 20 (1.0)

121 59 (0.52) N/A 170 (0.25) 147 (0.26) 27 (0.89)

190 24 (0.81) 23 (1.1) 27 (0.81) 39 (0.64) 30 (0.85)

thermodynamics 5,943 1 (25) 1 (31) 1 (25) 1 (23) 1 (25)

kinetics 883 3 (3.8) 6 (2.5) 8 (2.2) 3 (3.6) 3 (4.8) adsorption 736 5 (3.1) 11 (1.5) 10 (1.9) 6 (2.5) 4 (4.4)

thermodynamic 503 9 (2.1) 26 (1.0) 15 (1.3) 10 (2.1) 6 (2.7) phase diagram 545 7 (2.3) 21 (1.2) 6 (2.3) 9 (2.1) 7 (2.7) entropy 548 6 (2.3) 8 (2.0) 7 (2.2) 7 (2.5) 8 (2.4)

heat capacity 533 8 (2.3) 3 (2.6) 5 (2.7) 5 (2.8) 11 (1.7) calorimetry 503 9 (2.1) 5 (2.5) 4 (3.0) 8 (2.2) 12 (1.7) phase diagrams 260 17 (1.1) 26 (1.0) 31 (0.68) 25 (0.83) 13 (1.5) CALPHAD 186 25 (0.79) N/A 782 (0.068) 35 (0.66) 14 (1.3) solubility 325 14 (1.4) 10 (2.0) 16 (1.3) 13 (1.3) 14 (1.3) enthalpy 373 12 (1.6) 8 (2.0) 9 (1.9) 11 (1.7) 16 (1.3)

isotherm 120 60 (0.51) 1288 (0.045) 565 (0.09) 231 (0.18) 21 (1.0) equation of state 316 15 (1.3) 7 (2.4) 13 (1.7) 13 (1.3) 21 (1.0) density 178 27 (0.76) 29 (1.0) 41 (0.59) 60 (0.51) 23 (0.94) molecular dynamics 172 29 (0.73) 165 (0.27) 31 (0.68) 47 (0.61) 24 (0.93) free energy 163 33 (0.69) 165 (0.27) 52 (0.52) 51 (0.59) 25 (0.92) phase equilibria 228 19 (1.0) 32 (0.86) 25 (0.83) 18 (1.2) 26 (0.91) biosorption 101 72 (0.43) N/A N/A 431 (0.11) 27 (0.89)

phase transition 158 36 (0.67) 52 (0.64) 58 (0.47) 60 (0.51) 29 (0.86)

**Table 6.** The most frequently used 30 author keywords in 2006-2010

1996-2000 R (%)

2001-2005 R (%)

2006-2010 R (%)

Author keywords TP 1991-2010

thermodynamic properties

thermodynamic parameters

thermodynamic modeling

thermodynamic analysis

thermodynamic property

density functional

isothermal titration calorimetry

thermodynamic stability

theory

AB initio calculations

nonequilibrium thermodynamics

N/A: Not Available

Except the dominant language English, Russian, Chinese, French, Japanese and German were the most common languages. Above all, the growth process of annual thermodynamic scientific outputs can be divided into two stages, and the annual growth rate of the second stage 2004-2010 was four times of that in the first stage 1991-2003. Secondly, *Russian Journal of Physical Chemistry* was the most productive journal, and then *Journal of Alloys and Compounds and Journal of Chemical Physics*. The most common category was found to be physical chemistry. Thirdly, the global geographic distribution discovered that Europe took the leading position, following by Asia, America, Africa and Oceania. In particular, the eight major industrialized countries (G8: Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, Russia, the UK, and USA) played a prominent role with more than a half contribution, especially the USA. However, China experienced the greatest growth rate, and surpassed the USA in 2009 in terms of annual production, but needs to enhance its quality of publications. China and India had low collaboration rates while the UK, Netherlands, and Switzerland in Europe with a smaller size had high collaboration rates. In general, the thermodynamic research presented a higher international collaboration rate but a lower inter-institutional collaboration rate in comparison with other fields. Russian Academy of Sciences and Chinese Academy of Sciences took the leading position of institutions, following distantly by Tohoku University in Japan, and Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique in France. It was also revealed that the institutions with lower collaboration rates usually published greater proportion of first author articles and corresponding author articles, and vice versa. Finally, by analyzing the latest most frequently used author keywords, it was concluded that the items "thermodynamic properties", "kinetics", "adsorption", "thermodynamic parameters", "phase diagram", and "entropy" are the traditional research hotspots and will continue being the emphases in the foreseeable future. "CALPHAD", "density functional theory", "isothermal titration calorimetry", "isotherm", "biosorption", and "AB initio calculations", as the quickly increasing concernings, are the newly thermodynamic research hotspots.

Bibliometric Analysis of Thermodynamic Research: A Science Citation Index Expanded-Based Analysis 539

Chuang, K.Y., Wang, M.H. & Ho, Y.S. (2011). High-impact papers presented in the subject category of water resources in the Essential Science Indicators database of the institute for scientific information. *Scientometrics*, Vol.87, No.3, (June 2011), pp. 551-562, ISSN

Dehnen, S., Schafer, A., Ahlrichs, R. & Fenske, D. (1996). An AB initio study of structures and energetics of copper sulfide clusters. *Chemistry-A European Journal*, Vol.2, No.4,

Ferrara, S.D., Bajanowski, T., Cecchi, R., Boscolo-Berto, R. & Viel, G. (2011). Bio-medicolegal scientific research in Europe: a comprehensive bibliometric overview. *International* 

Fries, S.G. & Jantzen, T. (1998). Compilation of 'CALPHAD' formation enthalpy data - Binary intermetallic compounds in the COST507 Gibbsian database. *Thermochimica Acta*,

Fu, H.Z., Chuang, K.Y., Wang, M.H. & Ho, Y.S. (2011). Characteristics of research in China assessed with Essential Science Indicators. *Scientometrics*, Vol.88, No.3, (September

Fu, H.Z., Ho, Y.S., Sui, Y.M. & Li, Z.S. (2010). A bibliometric analysis of solid waste research during the period 1993-2008. *Waste Management*, Vol.30, No.12, (December 2010), pp.

Garfield, E. (1990). KeyWords PlusTM - ISIS breakthrough retrieval method. 1. Expanding your searching power on current-contents on diskette. *Current Contents*, Vol.32, (August

Garfield, E. (1996). How can impact factors be improved? *British Medical Journal*, Vol.313,

Garfield, E. & Sher, I.H. (1963). New factors in evaluation of scientific literature through citation indexing. *American Documentation*, Vol.14, No.3, pp. 195-201, ISSN 0096-946X Glänzel, W., Schubert, A. & Braun, T. (2002). A relational charting approach to the world of basic research in twelve science fields at the end of the second millennium.

Glänzel, W., Schubert, A. & Czerwon, H.J. (1999). A bibliometric analysis of international scientific cooperation of the European Union (1985-1995). *Scientometrics*, Vol.45, No.2,

Gmehling, J., Li, J.D. & Schiller, M. (1993). A modified UNIFAC model. 2. Present parameter matrix and results for different thermodynamic properties. *Industrial & Engineering* 

Goodman, B. (1993). Noted researchers laud donation to Russian science. *Scientist*, Vol.7,

Han, J.S. & Ho, Y.S. (2011). Global trends and performances of acupuncture research. *Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews*, Vol.35, No.3, (January 2011), pp. 680-687, ISSN

He, T.W. (2009). International scientific collaboration of China with the G7 countries.

*Chemistry Research*, Vol.32, No.1, (January 1993), pp. 178-193, ISSN 0888-5885

*Scientometrics*, Vol.80, No.3, (September 2009), pp. 571-582, ISSN 0138-9130

*Journal of Legal Medicine*, Vol.125, No.3, (May 2011), pp. 393-402, ISSN 0937-9827 Friedberg, A.L. (2000). Will Europe's past be Asia's future? *Survival*, Vol.42, No.3, pp. 147-59,

0138-9130

ISSN 0039-6338

1990), pp. 5-9

0149-7634

(April 1996), pp. 429-435, ISSN 0947-6539

2011), pp. 841-862, ISSN 0138-9130

2410-2417, ISSN 0956-053X

Vol.314, No.1-2, (April 1998), pp. 23-33, ISSN 0040-6031

No.7054, (August 1996), pp. 411-413, ISSN 0959-535X

*Scientometrics*, Vol.55, No.3, pp. 335-348, ISSN 0138-9130

(June 1999), pp. 185-202, ISSN 0138-9130

No.1, (January 1993), pp. 3, ISSN 0890-3670

## **Author details**

Hui-Zhen Fu1, Yuh-Shan Ho1,2,\*

*1Department of Environmental Sciences, Peking University, People's Republic of China 2Trend Research Centre, Asia University, Taiwan* 

## **5. References**


<sup>\*</sup> Corresponding Author

Chuang, K.Y., Wang, M.H. & Ho, Y.S. (2011). High-impact papers presented in the subject category of water resources in the Essential Science Indicators database of the institute for scientific information. *Scientometrics*, Vol.87, No.3, (June 2011), pp. 551-562, ISSN 0138-9130

538 Thermodynamics – Fundamentals and Its Application in Science

**Author details** 

**5. References** 

ISSN 0138-9130

Corresponding Author

 \*

Hui-Zhen Fu1, Yuh-Shan Ho1,2,\*

*2Trend Research Centre, Asia University, Taiwan* 

No.1, pp. 89-102, ISSN 0138-9130

However, China experienced the greatest growth rate, and surpassed the USA in 2009 in terms of annual production, but needs to enhance its quality of publications. China and India had low collaboration rates while the UK, Netherlands, and Switzerland in Europe with a smaller size had high collaboration rates. In general, the thermodynamic research presented a higher international collaboration rate but a lower inter-institutional collaboration rate in comparison with other fields. Russian Academy of Sciences and Chinese Academy of Sciences took the leading position of institutions, following distantly by Tohoku University in Japan, and Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique in France. It was also revealed that the institutions with lower collaboration rates usually published greater proportion of first author articles and corresponding author articles, and vice versa. Finally, by analyzing the latest most frequently used author keywords, it was concluded that the items "thermodynamic properties", "kinetics", "adsorption", "thermodynamic parameters", "phase diagram", and "entropy" are the traditional research hotspots and will continue being the emphases in the foreseeable future. "CALPHAD", "density functional theory", "isothermal titration calorimetry", "isotherm", "biosorption", and "AB initio calculations", as

the quickly increasing concernings, are the newly thermodynamic research hotspots.

*1Department of Environmental Sciences, Peking University, People's Republic of China* 

Vol.38, No.1, (September 2002), pp. 89-99, ISSN 0032-9592

No.5314, (May 1997), pp.917-922, ISSN 0036-8075

Wiley & Sons, pp. vii, ISBN 978-0-471-86256-7, USA

Vol.73, No.1, (October 2007), pp. 3-17, ISSN 0138-9130

Aksu, Z. (2002). Determination of the equilibrium, kinetic and thermodynamic parameters of the batch biosorption of nickel(II) ions onto Chlorella vulgaris. *Process Biochemistry*,

Alfaraz, P.H. & Calvino, A.M. (2004). Bibliometric study on food science and technology: Scientific production in Iberian-American countries (1991-2000). *Scientometrics*, Vol.61,

Astumian, R.D. (1997). Thermodynamics and kinetics of a Brownian motor. *Science*, Vol.276,

Callen, H.B. (1985). *Thermodynamics and an introduction to thermostatistics* (2nd Edition), John

Chiu, W.T. & Ho, Y.S. (2005). Bibliometric analysis of homeopathy research during the period of 1991 to 2003. *Scientometrics*, Vol.63, No.1, (April 2005), pp. 3-23, ISSN 0138-9130 Chiu, W.T. & Ho, Y.S. (2007). Bibliometric analysis of tsunami research. *Scientometrics*,

Chuang, K.Y., Huang, Y.L. & Ho, Y.S. (2007). A bibliometric and citation analysis of strokerelated research in Taiwan. *Scientometrics*, Vol.72, No.2, (August 2007), pp. 201-212,

	- Ho, Y.S. (2008). Bibliometric analysis of biosorption technology in water treatment research from 1991 to 2004. *International Journal of Environment and Pollution*, Vol.34, No.1-4, pp. 1-13, ISSN 0957-4352

Bibliometric Analysis of Thermodynamic Research: A Science Citation Index Expanded-Based Analysis 541

Moed, H.F. (2002). The impact-factors debate: the ISI's uses and limits. *Nature*, Vol.415,

Moed, H.F., de Bruin, R.E. & Van Leeuwen, Th.N. (1995). New bibliometric tools for the assessment of national research performance: Database description, overview of indicators and first applications. *Scientometrics*, Vol.33, No.3, (July-August 1995), pp.

Nagy, A. & Parr, R.G. (1994). Density-functional theory as thermodynamics. *Proceedings of the Indian Academy of Sciences-Chemical Sciences*, Vol.106, No.2, (April 1994), pp. 217-227,

Narin, F., Stevens, K. and Whitlow Edith S. (1991). Scientific co-operation in Europe and the citation of multinationally authored papers. *Scientometrics*, Vol.21, No.3, (July-August

Ngai, K.L. (2000). Dynamic and thermodynamic properties of glass-forming substances. *Journal of Non-Crystalline Solids*, Vol.275, No.1-2, (September 2000), pp. 7-51, ISSN 0022-

Nicholls, A., Sharp, K.A. & Honig, B. (1991). Protein folding and association - insights from the interfacial and thermodynamic properties of hydrocarbons. *Proteins-Structure* 

Oh, C.S., Shim, J.H., Lee, B.J.A. & Lee, D.N. (1996). Thermodynamic study on the Ag-Sb-Sn system. *Journal of Alloys and Compounds*, Vol.238, No.1-2, (May 1 1996), pp. 155-166, ISSN

Patzek, T.W. (2004). Thermodynamics of the corn-ethanol biofuel cycle. *Critical Reviews in* 

Picknett, T. & Davis, K. (1999). The 100 most-cited articles from JMB. *Journal of Molecular* 

Rehn,C., Kronman, U. & Wadskog, D. (2007). *Bibliometric indicators-definitions and usage at Karolinska Institutet*. in Karolinska Institutet, 13.03.2012, Available from

Sainte-Marie, B. (2010). The first 30 years of the journal of crustacean biology - a bibliometric study. *Journal of Crustacean Biology*, Vol.30, (November 2010), pp. 541-549, ISSN 0278-

SantaLucia, J. & Hicks, D. (2004). The thermodynamics of DNA structural motifs. *Annual Review of Biophysics and Biomolecular Structure*, Vol.33, pp.415-440, ISSN 1056-8700 Saracevi, T. & Perk, L.J. (1973). Ascertaining activities in a subject area through bibliometric analysis. *Journal of the American Society for Information Science*, Vol.24, No.2, pp. 120-134,

Schubert, A., Glänzel, W. & Braun, T. (1989). Scientometric datafiles: A comprehensive set of indicators on 2649 journals and 96 countries in all major science fields and subfields

1981-1985. *Scientometrics*, Vol.16, No.1-6, (June 1989), pp. 3-478, ISSN 0138-9130

http://kib.ki.se/sites/kib.ki.se/files/Bibliometric\_indicators\_definitions\_1.0.pdf Rosakis, P., Rosakis, A.J., Ravichandran, G. & Hodowany, J. (2000). A thermodynamic internal variable model for the partition of plastic work into heat and stored energy in metals. *Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids*, Vol.48, No.3, (March 2000), pp. 581-

*Function and Genetics*, Vol.11, No.4, pp. 281-296, ISSN 0887-3585

*Biology*, Vol.293, No.2, (October 1999), pp. 173-176, ISSN 0022-2836

*Plant Sciences*, Vol.23, No.6, pp. 519-567, ISSN 0735-2689

No.6873, (February 2002), pp. 731-732, ISSN 0028-0836

381-422, ISSN 0138-9130

1991), pp. 313-323, ISSN 0138-9130

ISSN 0253-4134

3093

0925-8388

607, ISSN 0022-5096

ISSN 0002-8231

0372


Moed, H.F. (2002). The impact-factors debate: the ISI's uses and limits. *Nature*, Vol.415, No.6873, (February 2002), pp. 731-732, ISSN 0028-0836

540 Thermodynamics – Fundamentals and Its Application in Science

2005), pp. 3455-3461, ISSN 1359-5113

Stockholm, Sweden, July 24-28, 2005

1993), pp. 475-481, ISSN 0002-7863

6047-6051, ISSN 0002-7863

California, USA

No.1-2, (May 2011), pp. 13-20, ISSN 0921-8181

1-13, ISSN 0957-4352

29608-4, New York, USA

Ho, Y.S. (2008). Bibliometric analysis of biosorption technology in water treatment research from 1991 to 2004. *International Journal of Environment and Pollution*, Vol.34, No.1-4, pp.

Ho, Y.S. & Ofomaja, A.E. (2005). Kinetics and thermodynamics of lead ion sorption on palm kernel fibre from aqueous solution. *Process Biochemistry*, Vol.40, No.11, (November

Ho, Y.S., Satoh, H. & Lin, S.Y. (2010). Japanese lung cancer research trends and performance in Science Citation Index. *Internal Medicine*, Vol.49, No.20, pp. 2219-2228, ISSN 0918-2918 Holman, J.P. (1985). *Thermodynamics* (3rd edition), McGraw-Hill, pp. 2, ISBN 978-0-070-

Jin, B.H. & Rousseau, R. (2005). China's quantitative expansion phase: Exponential growth but low impact. *ISSI 2005: Proceedings of the 10th International Conference of the International Society for Scientometrics and Informetrics*, pp. 362-370, ISBN 91-7140-339-6,

Inoue, Y., Hakushi, T., Liu, Y., Tong, L.H., Shen, B.J. & Jin, D.S. (1993a). Thermodynamics of molecular recognition by cyclodextrins. 1. Calorimetric titration of inclusion complexation of naphthalenesulfonates with -, -, and -cyclodextrin: enthalpy entropy compensation. *Journal of the American Chemical Society*, Vol.115, No.2, (January

Inoue, Y., Liu, Y., Tong, L.H., Shen, B.J. & Jin, D.S. (1993b). Thermodynamics of molecular recognition by cyclodextrins. Calorimetric titration of inclusion complexation with modified -cyclodextrins. Enthalpy-entropy compensation in host-guest complexation: From ionophore to cyclodextrin and cyclophane. *Journal of the American Chemical Society*,

Keizer, J. (1985). Heat, work, and the thermodynamic temperature at nonequilibrium steady-states. *Journal of Chemical Physics*, Vol.82, No.6, pp. 2751-2771, ISSN 0021-9606 Kleppa, O.J. (1952). A thermodynamic study of liquid metallic solutions. 4. approximate thermodynamic data from the phase diagram for the systems copper bismuth, copper lead and copper thallium. *Journal of the American Chemical Society*, Vol.74, No.23, pp.

Kocks, U.F., Argon, A.S. & Ashby, M.F. (1975). Thermodynamics and kinetics of slip.

Kostoff, R.N. (2008). Comparison of China/USA science and technology performance. *Journal* 

Li, J.F., Wang, M.H. & Ho, Y.S. (2011). Trends in research on global climate change: A Science Citation Index Expanded-based analysis. *Global and Planetary Change*, Vol.77,

Li, J.F., Zhang, Y.H., Wang, X.S. & Ho, Y.S. (2009). Bibliometric analysis of atmospheric simulation trends in meteorology and atmospheric science journals. *Croatica Chemica* 

Look, D.C. & Saucer, H.J. (1982). *Thermodynamics*, Wadsworth, pp.4, ISBN 978-0-818-50491-4,

Luukkonen, T. (1990). Bibliometrics and evaluation of research performance. *Annals of* 

*Progress in Materials Science*, Vol.19, No.1-281, pp. 1-281, ISSN 0079-6425

*of Informetrics*, Vol.2, No.4, (October 2008), pp. 354-363, ISSN 1751-1577

*Acta*, Vol.82, No.3, (December 2009), pp. 695-705, ISSN 0011-1643

*Medicine*, Vol.22, No.3, (June 1990), pp. 145-150, ISSN 0785-3890

Vol.115, No.23, (November 1993), pp. 10637-10644, ISSN 0002-7863


247-250, ISSN 0014-5793

13-21, ISSN 0025-326X

50-62, ISSN 1536-6367

(July 2005), pp. 314-314, ISSN 0028-0836

Vol.8, No.2, (January 1994), pp. 3, ISSN 0890-3670

2011), pp. 353-365, ISSN 1944-3994

Jülich, Germany, November 5–7, 2003

(February 1994), pp. 181-190, ISSN 0138-9130

*ISSI Newletter*, Vol.4, (March 2008), pp. 7-9

3994

Seelig, J. (2004). Thermodynamics of lipid-peptide interactions. *Biochimica Et Biophysica Acta-Biomembranes*, Vol.1666, No.1-2, (November 2004), pp. 40-50, ISSN 0005-2736

Shimba, N., Torigoe, H. and Takahashi, H., Masudaa, K., Shimadaa, I., Arataa, Y. & Saraib, A. (1995). Comparative thermodynamic analyses of the Fv, Fab\* and fab fragments of anti-dansyl mouse monoclonal antibody. *Febs Letters*, Vol.360, No.3, (March 6 1995), pp.

Sun, J.S., Wang, M.H. & Ho, Y.S. (2012). A historical review and bibliometric analysis of research on estuary pollution. *Marine Pollution Bulletin*, Vol.64, No.1, (January 2012), pp.

Svirbely, W.J. (1954). Thermodynamic data for the zinc indium system obtained from the phase diagram. *Journal of Physical Chemistry*, Vol.58, No.7, pp. 557-559, ISSN 0022-3654 Tanaka, H. & Ho, Y.S. (2011). Global trends and performances of desalination research. *Desalination and Water Treatment*, Vol.25, No.1-3, (January 2011), pp. 1-12, ISSN 1944-

Tsay, M.Y. (2008). A bibliometric analysis of hydrogen energy literature, 1965-2005.

van Raan, A.F.J. (2001). Bibliometrics and Internet: Some observations and expectations.

van Raan, A.F.J. (2005). For your citations only? Hot topics in bibliometric analysis. *Measurement: Interdisciplinary Research and Perspectives*, Vol.3, No.1, (January 2005), pp.

von Bubnoff, A. (2005). Asia squeezes Europe's lead in science. *Nature*, Vol.436, No.7049,

Wang, M.H., Li, J.F. & Ho, Y.S. (2011). Research articles published in water resources journals: A bibliometric analysis. *Desalination and Water Treatment*, Vo.28, No.1-3, (April

Wang, M.H., Yu, T.C. & Ho, Y.S. (2010). A bibliometric analysis of the performance of Water Research. *Scientometrics*, Vol.84, No.3, (September 2010), pp. 813-820, ISSN 0138-9130. Webb, T.D. (1994). Societies aid in large-scale effort to support Russian science. *Scientist*,

Weingart, P. (2003). Evaluation of research performance: The danger of numbers. *Schriften der Forschungszentrums Jülich: Vol II. Bibliometric analysis in science and research: Applications, benefits and limitations*, pp. 7-19, ISBN 3-89336-334-3, Forschungszentrums

Wilson, C.S. & Markusova, V.A. (2004). Changes in the scientific output of Russia from 1980 to 2000, as reflected in the Science Citation Index, in relation to national politico-

Yamazaki, S. (1994). Research activities in life sciences in Japan. *Scientometrics*, Vol.29, No.2,

Zhou, P. & Leydesdorff, L. (2006). The emergence of China as a leading nation in science.

Zhou, P. & Leydesdorff, L. (2008). China ranks second in scientific publications since 2006.

economic changes. *Scientometrics*, Vol.59, No.3, pp. 345-389, ISSN 0138-9130

*Research Policy*, Vol.35, (February 2006), pp. 83-104, ISSN 0048-7333

*Scientometrics*, Vol.75, No.3, (June 2008), pp. 421-438, ISSN 0138-9130

*Scientometrics*, Vol.50, No.1, (January 2001), pp. 59-63, ISSN 0138-9130

*Edited by Ricardo Morales-Rodriguez*

This book presents the selection of various high level contributions involving thermodynamics. The book goes from the fundamentals up to several applications in different scientific fields. The content of the book has been classified in six sections: Classical Thermodynamics, Statistical Thermodynamics, Property Prediction in Thermodynamics, Material and Products, Non Equilibrium and Thermodynamics in Diverse Areas. The classification of the book aims to provide to the reader the facility of finding the desired topic included in the book. It is expected that this collection of chapters will contribute to the state of the art in the thermodynamics area.

Photo by weltreisendertj / iStock

Thermodynamics - Fundamentals and Its Application in Science

Thermodynamics

Fundamentals and Its Application in Science

*Edited by Ricardo Morales-Rodriguez*