**Fighting Against Resistant Strains: The Case of Benzothiazinones and Dinitrobenzamides**

Silvia Buroni, Giovanna Riccardi and Maria Rosalia Pasca *Department of Genetics and Microbiology, University of Pavia Italy* 

## **1. Introduction**

272 Understanding Tuberculosis – New Approaches to Fighting Against Drug Resistance

Ryll, R.; Kumazawa, Y. & Yano, I. (2001). Immunological properties of trehalose dimycolate

Schraufstätter, E. (1950). Formation of heavy-metal complexes and antibacterial action. Z

Schreck, R.; Meier, B.; Männel, D.N.; Dröge, W. & Baeuerle, P.A. (1992). Dithiocarbamates as

Shah, D.T.; Walker, E.M. Jr.; Jones, M.M.; Singh, P.K. & Larsen, B. (1997). Inhibitory effects of

Taylor, E.H.; Walker, E.M. Jr.; Bartelt, M.; Day, S. & Pappas, A.A. (1987). In vitro

Thorn, G. D. & Ludwig, R.A. (1967). The Dithiocarbamates and Related Compounds.

Vaddady, P.K.; Lee, R.E. & Meibohm, B. (2010). In vitro pharmacokinetic/pharmacodynamic

van Heijenoort, J. (2001). Formation of the glycan chains in the synthesis of bacterial peptidoglycan. *Glycobiology*, Vol.11, No.3, (March 2001), pp. 25R-36R, ISSN van Raalte, M.H. (1952). A test for the translocation of fungicides through plant tissues. C.R.

Weuffen, W.; Göckeritz, D. & Pohloudek-Fabini, R. (1967). Correlation between chemical

Weuffen, W.; Göckeritz, D. & Pohloudek-Fabini, R. (1967). Correlation between chemical

Wilson, N.K. & Fishbein, L. (1972) Decomposition of tetrakis (N,N-

Wolucka, B.A. (2008). Biosynthesis of D-arabinose in mycobacteria - a novel bacterial

http://www.who.int/tb/publications/global\_report/2010/en/index.html

IIIe C0ngr. int. Phytopharm., Paris, (1952), pp. 76-78, ISSN

*Ann Clin Lab Sci*, Vol.27, No.4, (July-August 1997), pp. 282-286, ISSN Sisler, H.D. & Marshall, N.L. (1957). Physiological effects of certainn fungitoxic compounds

on fungus cells. *J Washington Acad Sci*, Vol.47, (1957), pp. 321, ISSN

*Immunol*, Vol.45, No.12, (2001), pp. 801-811, ISSN

Vol.175, No.5, (May 1992), pp. 1181-1194, ISSN

Naturforsch, Vol.5b, (1950), pp. 190, ISSN

June 1987), pp. 171-177, ISSN

Elsevier, Amsterdam. 1962.

No.8, (August 2010), pp. 1355-1369, ISSN

No.9, (September 1967), pp.506-510, ISSN

No.9, (September 1967), pp.510-517, ISSN

World Health Organization, (2010), Global tuberculosis control,

(June 2008), pp. 2691-2711, ISSN World Health Organization, (2001), The Stop TB Strategy,

http://www.who.int/tb/strategy/en/

847–850, ISSN

(cord factor) and other mycolic acid-containing glycolipids--a review. *Microbiol* 

potent inhibitors of nuclear factor kappa B activation in intact cells. *J Exp Med*,

seven organosulphur compounds on clinical isolates of Candida species in vitro.

antimicrobial activity of diethyldithiocarbamate and dimethyldithiocarbamate against methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus. *Ann Clin Lab Sci*,Vol.17, No.3, (May-

models in anti-infective drug development: focus on TB. *Future Med Chem*, Vol.2,

constitution and antimicrobial effect. 14. On the bacteriostatic and fungistatic properties on various aliphatic and aromatic isothiocyanates as wells as the analogous amines, dithiocarbamate and thioureacompounds. I. *Pharmazie*, Vol.22,

structure and antimicronial effect. 17. On the bacreriostatic and fungistatic properties of various aliphatic and aromatic isothiocyanates as well as the analogous amines, dithiocarbamate and thiourea compounds. II. *Pharmazie*, Vol.22,

diethyldithiocarbamato)selenium(IV). *J Agric Food Chem*, Vol. 20, No.4, (1972), pp.

pathway with implications for antimycobacterial therapy. FEBS J, Vol.275, No.11,

The resurgence of tuberculosis is ascribed to several factors such as: large scale migration, co-infection with immunodeficiency virus, and the emergence of *Mycobacterium tuberculosis*  drug-resistant strains.

Drug-resistant tuberculosis is a growing global health problem. This has led to an increased urgency to understand the molecular mechanisms of drug action and drug resistance, which could give significant insight into the development of new compounds. New molecules should be useful to fight both drug-susceptible as well as drug-resistant strains (Caminero et al., 2010).

It is noteworthy that the development of drug-resistant *M. tuberculosis* strains is essentially favored by an inappropriate drug prescription of physicians and irregular intake of the drugs by patients (Goldman et al., 2007). Bacterial resistance to antibiotics typically involves drug inactivation or modification, target alteration, diminished drug accumulation associated with decrease in permeability and/or increase in efflux. Other resistance mechanisms include inhibition of the activation of pro-drugs into active drugs. Bacterial resistance may be an intrinsic feature of an organism, or may result from spontaneous mutations or the acquisition of exogenous resistance genes. As *M. tuberculosis* does not possess plasmids and horizontal gene transfer is thought to be rare, all resistances appear to emerge through mutations in chromosomal genes (Gillespie, 2007). Chromosomal alterations that result in resistance to antitubercular drugs may be associated with a fitness cost. Based on work in experimental models and from observations in clinical drug resistant isolates, it has been observed that among the various resistance mutations that appear with similar rates, those associated with the least fitness cost are selected in the population (Böttger and Springer, 2008). Consequently, to reduce the rate of spread of resistant bacteria it is necessary to identify targets for which the resistance mechanisms have the most negative effects on bacterial fitness. *M. tuberculosis* shows a high degree of intrinsic resistance to several antibiotics and chemotherapeutic agents attributed to the low permeability of its cell wall, in particular because of its specific lipid-rich composition and structure (Jarlier and Nikaido, 1994). However, some reports have suggested that efflux pumps may also be involved (De Rossi et al., 2006). The balance between the drug transport into the cell and drug efflux is not yet clearly understood, and further studies are required in

Fighting Against Resistant Strains: The Case of Benzothiazinones and Dinitrobenzamides 275

identify essential *M. tuberculosis* genes (Lamichhane et al., 2005; Sassetti et al., 2003; Sassetti and Rubin, 2003). The functional categories to which these genes belong are: lipid metabolism; carbohydrate, amino acid, inorganic ion and nucleotide transport and metabolism; energy production and conversion; secretion; cell envelope biosynthesis; cell division; DNA replication, recombination and repair; transcription and translation; posttranslational modification; chaperones; coenzyme metabolism; signal transduction. These essential mycobacterial genes could encode good targets for tuberculosis drug development. Another intriguing field of research concerns the metabolism of several molecules,

The use of protein structure data to design molecules, that are most likely to interact with inhibitable proteins, constitute another field of research, aimed to create novel classes of *ad hoc* inhibitors able to interact with a bacterial protein and block its function. Thanks to the efforts of the Tuberculosis Structural Genomics, more than 260 X-ray crystal structures of interesting proteins have been completed (Chim et al., 2011). The availability of these structures provides the opportunity to carry out virtual screenings for drug discovery. Virtual screening can be used to identify compounds that are consistent with a pharmacophore model, without considering the target/s or to develop inhibitors of a protein, on a known three-dimensional structure. The pharmaceutical industry has favoured this target-based approach to drug discovery. While successful in some cases, this high throughput screening approach has failed miserably in the antibacterial discovery area (Payne et al., 2007; Fischbach and Walsh, 2009). Also in our own experience, target-based screens generate hits but these usually fail to show useful minimum inhibitory concentrations against *M. tuberculosis.* The reasons for this collective failure remain unclear but may include the inability of many synthetic compounds to enter bacteria and find their

target, the presence of efflux systems or other innate resistance mechanisms.

For tuberculosis drug discovery the research process has often begun either *via* phenotypic screening of compound libraries against *M. tuberculosis* or a surrogate organism, such as *Mycobacterium smegmatis* or *Mycobacterium bovis* BCG growing *in vitro* culture, or against a target of interest. This effort has created the pipeline of new candidate drugs at various stages of preclinical and early clinical evaluations (Lenaerts et al., 2008; Lienhardt et al.,

In the last five years, within the European Community network, the "New Medicines for Tuberculosis" consortium (to which our laboratory belongs) has been working to successfully develop new drugs for the treatment of tuberculosis through an integrated approach (http://www.sciprom.ch/nm4tb/). The group has just obtained new funding from the European Community with the project "More Medicines for Tuberculosis". Development and implementation of novel enabling technologies required for drug development, target validation in well-established areas such as the central metabolism, cell wall and nucleic acid synthesis, in addition to more challenging yet highly innovative topics, are the major expected results of the network. Within this project, a new effective antimycobacterial agent, belonging to the nitrobenzothiazinone class and with a minimal inhibitory concentration of 1 ng/ml, that quickly kills *M. tuberculosis in vitro*, *ex vivo* and in murine models of tuberculosis, has been discovered (Makarov et al., 2009). The lead compound benzothiazin-4-one (BTZ038) has a single chiral center, and both enantiomers, BTZ043 (S) and BTZ044 (R), were found to be equipotent *in vitro*. This drug is also active

important for bacterial survival.

2010; Riccardi et al., 2009).

mycobacteria (De Rossi et al., 2006). The development of mycobacterial resistance to antibiotics has co-evolved over time with the discovery of antitubercular drugs. Indeed, *M. tuberculosis* mutants resistant to any single drug were identified and most of them characterized.

Drugs utilized to treat tuberculosis are classified into first-line (isoniazid, rifampicin, pyrazinamide, and ethambutol) and second-line agents (quinolones, aminoglycosides, linezolid, ethionamide, and *D*-cycloserine). The commonly used antitubercular regimen is based on four first-line agents: isoniazid, rifampin, pyrazinamide, and ethambutol, for the first two months, followed by rifampin and isoniazid treatment for a further four months, as recommended by the World Health Organization.

Strains of *M. tuberculosis* that are resistant to both isoniazid and rifampicin, with or without resistance to other drugs, named multidrug-resistant strains (MDR-TB), require a further two years of treatment with second-line drugs such as: quinolones, aminoglycosides, ethionamide, *D*-cycloserine and basic peptides. The emergence of Extensively drug-resistant tuberculosis (XDR-TB), caused by MDR-strains also resistant to two major second-line agents (aminoglycosides and fluoroquinolones), greatly alarmed the World Health Organization. These resistant strains have been identified in all regions of the World, most often in Asia and countries of the former Soviet Union (Caminero et al., 2010).

Beside the problem of XDR-TB cases, which remains unresolved in many regions of the World, new totally drug-resistant strains (TDR), or super XDR-TB isolates, have been reported. *M. tuberculosis* isolates are defined TDR if they are resistant to all first-line (isoniazid, rifampicin, streptomycin, ethambutol, and pyrazinamide) and second-line drugs (quinolones, aminoglycosides, linezolid, ethionamide, and *D*-cycloserine) (Velayati et al., 2009). Generally, the spectrum of resistance reflects the drugs that the patients have used and the way in which therapy was controlled.

The treatment of tuberculosis becomes more complicated as the antibiotic resistance profile of *M. tuberculosis* broadens. MDR and XDR tuberculosis are generally thought to have high mortality rates; for TDR-TB there are no drugs available. In fact, with the exception of the fluoroquinolones, no new antitubercular drug has been introduced in therapy in the past 45 years (Caminero et al., 2010).

In recent years, the increasing concern for drug resistance has hurried the need for the development of new control measures. At present, the identification of new drugs and new cellular targets is prioritised (Riccardi et al., 2009).

Presently, ten compounds with antitubercular activity have entered clinical trials (Lenaerts et al., 2008; Riccardi et al., 2009), while other promising ones are still in pre-clinical development (Lienhardt et al., 2010). This has been prompted since the availability of the *M. tuberculosis* genome sequence (Cole et al., 1998), when several Laboratories in the World have utilized the genomic data to identify and validate targets as starting point for the development of new antitubercular drugs. Genomic sequence information allows also the use of comparative genomic analysis to identify new potential targets, and provides some assurance against mammalian toxicity if homologous proteins are absent from mammalian sequence databases. Sequence similarities can also give useful hints on putative protein functions. Transposon mutagenesis and signature-tagged mutagenesis have been used to

mycobacteria (De Rossi et al., 2006). The development of mycobacterial resistance to antibiotics has co-evolved over time with the discovery of antitubercular drugs. Indeed, *M. tuberculosis* mutants resistant to any single drug were identified and most of them

Drugs utilized to treat tuberculosis are classified into first-line (isoniazid, rifampicin, pyrazinamide, and ethambutol) and second-line agents (quinolones, aminoglycosides, linezolid, ethionamide, and *D*-cycloserine). The commonly used antitubercular regimen is based on four first-line agents: isoniazid, rifampin, pyrazinamide, and ethambutol, for the first two months, followed by rifampin and isoniazid treatment for a further four months, as

Strains of *M. tuberculosis* that are resistant to both isoniazid and rifampicin, with or without resistance to other drugs, named multidrug-resistant strains (MDR-TB), require a further two years of treatment with second-line drugs such as: quinolones, aminoglycosides, ethionamide, *D*-cycloserine and basic peptides. The emergence of Extensively drug-resistant tuberculosis (XDR-TB), caused by MDR-strains also resistant to two major second-line agents (aminoglycosides and fluoroquinolones), greatly alarmed the World Health Organization. These resistant strains have been identified in all regions of the World, most

Beside the problem of XDR-TB cases, which remains unresolved in many regions of the World, new totally drug-resistant strains (TDR), or super XDR-TB isolates, have been reported. *M. tuberculosis* isolates are defined TDR if they are resistant to all first-line (isoniazid, rifampicin, streptomycin, ethambutol, and pyrazinamide) and second-line drugs (quinolones, aminoglycosides, linezolid, ethionamide, and *D*-cycloserine) (Velayati et al., 2009). Generally, the spectrum of resistance reflects the drugs that the patients have used

The treatment of tuberculosis becomes more complicated as the antibiotic resistance profile of *M. tuberculosis* broadens. MDR and XDR tuberculosis are generally thought to have high mortality rates; for TDR-TB there are no drugs available. In fact, with the exception of the fluoroquinolones, no new antitubercular drug has been introduced in therapy in the past 45

In recent years, the increasing concern for drug resistance has hurried the need for the development of new control measures. At present, the identification of new drugs and new

Presently, ten compounds with antitubercular activity have entered clinical trials (Lenaerts et al., 2008; Riccardi et al., 2009), while other promising ones are still in pre-clinical development (Lienhardt et al., 2010). This has been prompted since the availability of the *M. tuberculosis* genome sequence (Cole et al., 1998), when several Laboratories in the World have utilized the genomic data to identify and validate targets as starting point for the development of new antitubercular drugs. Genomic sequence information allows also the use of comparative genomic analysis to identify new potential targets, and provides some assurance against mammalian toxicity if homologous proteins are absent from mammalian sequence databases. Sequence similarities can also give useful hints on putative protein functions. Transposon mutagenesis and signature-tagged mutagenesis have been used to

often in Asia and countries of the former Soviet Union (Caminero et al., 2010).

characterized.

recommended by the World Health Organization.

and the way in which therapy was controlled.

cellular targets is prioritised (Riccardi et al., 2009).

years (Caminero et al., 2010).

identify essential *M. tuberculosis* genes (Lamichhane et al., 2005; Sassetti et al., 2003; Sassetti and Rubin, 2003). The functional categories to which these genes belong are: lipid metabolism; carbohydrate, amino acid, inorganic ion and nucleotide transport and metabolism; energy production and conversion; secretion; cell envelope biosynthesis; cell division; DNA replication, recombination and repair; transcription and translation; posttranslational modification; chaperones; coenzyme metabolism; signal transduction. These essential mycobacterial genes could encode good targets for tuberculosis drug development. Another intriguing field of research concerns the metabolism of several molecules, important for bacterial survival.

The use of protein structure data to design molecules, that are most likely to interact with inhibitable proteins, constitute another field of research, aimed to create novel classes of *ad hoc* inhibitors able to interact with a bacterial protein and block its function. Thanks to the efforts of the Tuberculosis Structural Genomics, more than 260 X-ray crystal structures of interesting proteins have been completed (Chim et al., 2011). The availability of these structures provides the opportunity to carry out virtual screenings for drug discovery. Virtual screening can be used to identify compounds that are consistent with a pharmacophore model, without considering the target/s or to develop inhibitors of a protein, on a known three-dimensional structure. The pharmaceutical industry has favoured this target-based approach to drug discovery. While successful in some cases, this high throughput screening approach has failed miserably in the antibacterial discovery area (Payne et al., 2007; Fischbach and Walsh, 2009). Also in our own experience, target-based screens generate hits but these usually fail to show useful minimum inhibitory concentrations against *M. tuberculosis.* The reasons for this collective failure remain unclear but may include the inability of many synthetic compounds to enter bacteria and find their target, the presence of efflux systems or other innate resistance mechanisms.

For tuberculosis drug discovery the research process has often begun either *via* phenotypic screening of compound libraries against *M. tuberculosis* or a surrogate organism, such as *Mycobacterium smegmatis* or *Mycobacterium bovis* BCG growing *in vitro* culture, or against a target of interest. This effort has created the pipeline of new candidate drugs at various stages of preclinical and early clinical evaluations (Lenaerts et al., 2008; Lienhardt et al., 2010; Riccardi et al., 2009).

In the last five years, within the European Community network, the "New Medicines for Tuberculosis" consortium (to which our laboratory belongs) has been working to successfully develop new drugs for the treatment of tuberculosis through an integrated approach (http://www.sciprom.ch/nm4tb/). The group has just obtained new funding from the European Community with the project "More Medicines for Tuberculosis". Development and implementation of novel enabling technologies required for drug development, target validation in well-established areas such as the central metabolism, cell wall and nucleic acid synthesis, in addition to more challenging yet highly innovative topics, are the major expected results of the network. Within this project, a new effective antimycobacterial agent, belonging to the nitrobenzothiazinone class and with a minimal inhibitory concentration of 1 ng/ml, that quickly kills *M. tuberculosis in vitro*, *ex vivo* and in murine models of tuberculosis, has been discovered (Makarov et al., 2009). The lead compound benzothiazin-4-one (BTZ038) has a single chiral center, and both enantiomers, BTZ043 (S) and BTZ044 (R), were found to be equipotent *in vitro*. This drug is also active

Fighting Against Resistant Strains: The Case of Benzothiazinones and Dinitrobenzamides 277

target and from target to drug. Until now the first one appears to be the most easily attainable, leading to the discovery of new molecules which are currently in clinical trials and the last published benzothiazinones and dinitrobenzamides. However, we should remember that there is a high attrition rate during clinical trials before a candidate is approved for human use and resistance to new compounds will eventually arise, so drug

The class of Benzothiazinones (BTZs) comprises a series of sulfur-containing heterocycle compounds with antibacterial and antifungal activity (Makarov et al., 2006). One of BTZs, 2- [2-methyl-1,4-dioxa-8-azaspiro[4.5]dec-8-yl]-8-nitro-6-(trifluoromethyl)-4H-1,3 benzothiazin-

This compound was synthesized in seven steps with a yield of 36%. Structure activity relationship work showed that the sulfur atom and the nitro group at positions 1 and 8, respectively, were critical for activity. BTZ038 has a single chiral center, and both

The minimal inhibitory concentrations (MICs) of a variety of BTZs against different mycobacteria were very low, ranging from ~0.1 to 80 ng/ml for fast growers and from 1 to 30 ng/ml for members of the *M. tuberculosis* complex. The MIC of BTZ043 against *M. tuberculosis* H37Rv and *M. smegmatis* were 1 ng/ml (2.3 nM) and 4 ng/ml (9.2 nM), respectively (Makarov et al., 2009), indicating that this compound is more potent than isoniazid (500 ng/ml). BTZ043 displayed similar activity against all clinical isolates of *M.* 

enantiomers, BTZ043 (S) and BTZ044 (R), were found to be equipotent *in vitro*.

*tuberculosis* that were tested, including MDR and XDR strains (Makarov et al., 2009).

BTZ043 is bactericidal, reducing viability *in vitro* by more than 1000-fold in under 72 hours. The uptake, intracellular killing, and potential cytotoxicity of BTZ compounds in an *ex vivo* model using a high-content screening approach (Fenistein et al., 2008), in order to monitor macrophages infected with *M. tuberculosis* expressing the green fluorescent protein, were determined. Macrophages treated with BTZ043 were protected as compared with those

The *in vivo* efficacy of BTZ043 was assessed 4 weeks after a low-dose aerosol infection of BALB/c mice in the chronic model of tuberculosis. Four weeks of treatment with BTZ043 reduced the bacterial burden in the lungs and spleens by 1 and 2 logs, respectively, at the

4-one (BTZ038), was selected for further studies (Figure 1; Makarov et al., 2009).

Fig. 1. **Chemical structure of the lead compound BTZ038.**

treated with the negative controls (Makarov et al., 2009).

discovery efforts should be intensified.

**2. Benzothiazinones** 

against extensively- and multi-drug resistant clinical isolates, and it is in the pre-clinical trial phase. A huge amount of genetic and biochemical data indicates that DprE1 is the target of benzothiazinones (Makarov et al., 2009). DprE1 enzyme works in concert with DprE2 to catalyse the epimerization of decaprenyl-D-ribose to decaprenyl-D-arabinose in the biosynthesis of arabinogalactan, a fundamental component of mycobacterial cell wall (Wolucka, 2008). The DprE1 enzyme thus represents a proven vulnerable antimycobacterial drug target that could turn out magic for tuberculosis treatment (Manina et al., 2010b). In order to monitor the potential development of benzothiazinone-resistance, a total of 240 sensitive and MDR clinical isolates from four European hospitals were surveyed for the presence of mutations in the *dprE1* gene and for benzothiazinone susceptibility. All 240 strains were susceptible, thus establishing the baseline prior to the introduction of BTZ043 in clinical trials (Pasca et al., 2010).

Moreover, it has been shown that DprE1 is the target also of another class of very promising drugs, the dinitrobenzamides (Christophe et al., 2009). These compounds are active against mycobacteria and non toxic for the host cell, and they have been identified through the screening of chemicals which interfere with *M. tuberculosis* replication within macrophages (Christophe *et al*., 2009). In particular, the dinitrobenzamide derivatives were found to be highly active against *M. tuberculosis*. Two compounds were selected, N-(2-(4 methoxyphenoxy) ethyl)-3,5-dinitrobenzamide and N-(2-(benzyloxy) ethyl)-3,5 dinitrobenzamide, for further studies and target identification. Analysis of the broad antimicrobial spectrum was undertaken and revealed that the effect of these dinitrobenzamide derivatives has the most potent activity observed against mycobacteria with a minimal inhibitory concentration of 75 ng/ml. Of particular importance, these compounds were also highly active against MDR- and XDR-TB clinical isolates. In order to gain insight into the possible targets of dinitrobenzamides, the effect of these chemicals on the lipid composition of the cell envelope of *M. tuberculosis* was investigated; results showed that they affected the synthesis of the arabinan domains of arabinogalactan and lipoarabinomannan. In particular, analyses revealed complete inhibition of decaprenylphospho-arabinose formation in the dinitrobenzamide-treated extract concurrent with the accumulation of decaprenyl-phospho-ribose, indicating that the target of both dinitrobenzamide inhibitors is probably the heteromeric decaprenyl-phospho-ribose 2' epimerase.

Our group also identified and characterized a novel resistance mechanism to benzothiazinones in *M. smegmatis* (Manina et al., 2010a), and this mechanism was confirmed also for dinitrobenzamides (M.R. Pasca, personal communication). The over-expression of the nitroreductase NfnB led to the inactivation of the drug by reduction of a critical *nitro*group to an *amino*-group. The direct involvement of NfnB in the inactivation of the lead compound BTZ043 was demonstrated by enzymology, microbiological assays and gene knockout experiments. The crystal structure of NfnB and docking analysis of NfnBbenzothiazinones have been performed in order to understand their interaction and the mechanism of nitroreduction (Manina et al., 2010a). Although *M*. *tuberculosis* seems to lack nitroreductases able to inactivate these drugs, our findings are valuable for the design of new benzothiazinones, which may be more effective *in vivo*.

In conclusion many approaches are utilized to fight tuberculosis. The two principal research routes to find out new antibacterial molecules and novel bacterial targets are from drug to target and from target to drug. Until now the first one appears to be the most easily attainable, leading to the discovery of new molecules which are currently in clinical trials and the last published benzothiazinones and dinitrobenzamides. However, we should remember that there is a high attrition rate during clinical trials before a candidate is approved for human use and resistance to new compounds will eventually arise, so drug discovery efforts should be intensified.

## **2. Benzothiazinones**

276 Understanding Tuberculosis – New Approaches to Fighting Against Drug Resistance

against extensively- and multi-drug resistant clinical isolates, and it is in the pre-clinical trial phase. A huge amount of genetic and biochemical data indicates that DprE1 is the target of benzothiazinones (Makarov et al., 2009). DprE1 enzyme works in concert with DprE2 to catalyse the epimerization of decaprenyl-D-ribose to decaprenyl-D-arabinose in the biosynthesis of arabinogalactan, a fundamental component of mycobacterial cell wall (Wolucka, 2008). The DprE1 enzyme thus represents a proven vulnerable antimycobacterial drug target that could turn out magic for tuberculosis treatment (Manina et al., 2010b). In order to monitor the potential development of benzothiazinone-resistance, a total of 240 sensitive and MDR clinical isolates from four European hospitals were surveyed for the presence of mutations in the *dprE1* gene and for benzothiazinone susceptibility. All 240 strains were susceptible, thus establishing the baseline prior to the introduction of BTZ043 in

Moreover, it has been shown that DprE1 is the target also of another class of very promising drugs, the dinitrobenzamides (Christophe et al., 2009). These compounds are active against mycobacteria and non toxic for the host cell, and they have been identified through the screening of chemicals which interfere with *M. tuberculosis* replication within macrophages (Christophe *et al*., 2009). In particular, the dinitrobenzamide derivatives were found to be highly active against *M. tuberculosis*. Two compounds were selected, N-(2-(4 methoxyphenoxy) ethyl)-3,5-dinitrobenzamide and N-(2-(benzyloxy) ethyl)-3,5 dinitrobenzamide, for further studies and target identification. Analysis of the broad antimicrobial spectrum was undertaken and revealed that the effect of these dinitrobenzamide derivatives has the most potent activity observed against mycobacteria with a minimal inhibitory concentration of 75 ng/ml. Of particular importance, these compounds were also highly active against MDR- and XDR-TB clinical isolates. In order to gain insight into the possible targets of dinitrobenzamides, the effect of these chemicals on the lipid composition of the cell envelope of *M. tuberculosis* was investigated; results showed that they affected the synthesis of the arabinan domains of arabinogalactan and lipoarabinomannan. In particular, analyses revealed complete inhibition of decaprenylphospho-arabinose formation in the dinitrobenzamide-treated extract concurrent with the accumulation of decaprenyl-phospho-ribose, indicating that the target of both dinitrobenzamide inhibitors is probably the heteromeric decaprenyl-phospho-ribose 2'

Our group also identified and characterized a novel resistance mechanism to benzothiazinones in *M. smegmatis* (Manina et al., 2010a), and this mechanism was confirmed also for dinitrobenzamides (M.R. Pasca, personal communication). The over-expression of the nitroreductase NfnB led to the inactivation of the drug by reduction of a critical *nitro*group to an *amino*-group. The direct involvement of NfnB in the inactivation of the lead compound BTZ043 was demonstrated by enzymology, microbiological assays and gene knockout experiments. The crystal structure of NfnB and docking analysis of NfnBbenzothiazinones have been performed in order to understand their interaction and the mechanism of nitroreduction (Manina et al., 2010a). Although *M*. *tuberculosis* seems to lack nitroreductases able to inactivate these drugs, our findings are valuable for the design of

In conclusion many approaches are utilized to fight tuberculosis. The two principal research routes to find out new antibacterial molecules and novel bacterial targets are from drug to

new benzothiazinones, which may be more effective *in vivo*.

clinical trials (Pasca et al., 2010).

epimerase.

The class of Benzothiazinones (BTZs) comprises a series of sulfur-containing heterocycle compounds with antibacterial and antifungal activity (Makarov et al., 2006). One of BTZs, 2- [2-methyl-1,4-dioxa-8-azaspiro[4.5]dec-8-yl]-8-nitro-6-(trifluoromethyl)-4H-1,3 benzothiazin-4-one (BTZ038), was selected for further studies (Figure 1; Makarov et al., 2009).

#### Fig. 1. **Chemical structure of the lead compound BTZ038.**

This compound was synthesized in seven steps with a yield of 36%. Structure activity relationship work showed that the sulfur atom and the nitro group at positions 1 and 8, respectively, were critical for activity. BTZ038 has a single chiral center, and both enantiomers, BTZ043 (S) and BTZ044 (R), were found to be equipotent *in vitro*.

The minimal inhibitory concentrations (MICs) of a variety of BTZs against different mycobacteria were very low, ranging from ~0.1 to 80 ng/ml for fast growers and from 1 to 30 ng/ml for members of the *M. tuberculosis* complex. The MIC of BTZ043 against *M. tuberculosis* H37Rv and *M. smegmatis* were 1 ng/ml (2.3 nM) and 4 ng/ml (9.2 nM), respectively (Makarov et al., 2009), indicating that this compound is more potent than isoniazid (500 ng/ml). BTZ043 displayed similar activity against all clinical isolates of *M. tuberculosis* that were tested, including MDR and XDR strains (Makarov et al., 2009).

BTZ043 is bactericidal, reducing viability *in vitro* by more than 1000-fold in under 72 hours.

The uptake, intracellular killing, and potential cytotoxicity of BTZ compounds in an *ex vivo* model using a high-content screening approach (Fenistein et al., 2008), in order to monitor macrophages infected with *M. tuberculosis* expressing the green fluorescent protein, were determined. Macrophages treated with BTZ043 were protected as compared with those treated with the negative controls (Makarov et al., 2009).

The *in vivo* efficacy of BTZ043 was assessed 4 weeks after a low-dose aerosol infection of BALB/c mice in the chronic model of tuberculosis. Four weeks of treatment with BTZ043 reduced the bacterial burden in the lungs and spleens by 1 and 2 logs, respectively, at the

Fighting Against Resistant Strains: The Case of Benzothiazinones and Dinitrobenzamides 279

In order to monitor the potential development of BTZ resistance, a total of 240 sensitive and multidrug-resistant *M. tuberculosis* clinical isolates from four European hospitals were surveyed for the presence of mutations in the *dprE1* gene and for BTZ susceptibility (Pasca

The pharmaceutical industry usually estimates the likelihood of the development of resistance against a new drug by focusing on the mutation resistance rate, on the assumption that this rate is a major determinant of resistance development in clinical settings (Andersson, 2006). Therefore, drug targets for which the resistance mechanisms have the most negative effect on fitness are expected to show a low resistance development rate (Andersson, 2006). It is noteworthy that *in vitro M. tuberculosis* BTZ-resistant mutants were rare, arising at a frequency of 10-8 (Makarov et al., 2009) and they have not a good

The *M. tuberculosis* clinical isolates (including MDR- and XDR-TB strains) from four different European hospitals were screened for mutations in the Cys387 codon of *dprE1* and for BTZ sensitivity. Seventy-eight *M. tuberculosis* clinical isolates came from the National Institute for Infectious Diseases (INMI) "L. Spallanzani" hospital in Rome, Italy; 118 strains were isolated at the Sondalo Division of the Valtellina and Valchiavenna, Italy, hospital authority; 32 clinical isolates were from the "Ambroise Paré" Hospital in Boulogne-Billancourt, France; and 12 strains were isolated at the "Central Institute of Tuberculosis" in Moscow, Russia. All strains were isolated between 2003 and 2009 and 1 was an XDR strain and 38 (15.8%) had an MDR phenotype. Moreover, 35 MDR strains were resistant to other first- and second-line drugs and they were sensitive to only a few drugs. Some *M. tuberculosis* clinical isolates were resistant to one or more drugs but did not meet the MDR definition (24.6%). Seven *M. tuberculosis* clinical strains were isolated from HIV-positive patients. The *dprE1* gene was amplified by PCR and sequenced from all clinical isolates. None of the *M. tuberculosis* isolates had mutations in the *dprE1* gene, and hence, these isolates were presumably sensitive to BTZ (Pasca et al., 2010). This result confirms that BTZ resistance mutations are not present in the strains of *M. tuberculosis* currently circulating.

From these results, it is reasonable to hypothesize that the cysteine residue has a

To confirm this hypothesis, we showed that all the *M. tuberculosis* clinical isolates were sensitive to BTZ043, with values ranging from 0.75 to 30 ng/ml. This result confirms that BTZ043 is very active against both sensitive and resistant strains of *M. tuberculosis*, including

These results have very important implications for future clinical trials. Specifically, it will be possible to perform an easy and rapid diagnostic test for BTZ resistance in clinical isolates simply by sequencing the *dprE1* gene around the Cys387 codon or by using a real time-PCR

Given the previous results, the BTZs have been shown to be a new class of potent

Other information about the binding between the BTZs and their target came from Trefzer and collaborators that demonstrated that BTZs are activated in the bacterium by reduction

fundamental role in BTZ sensitivity, possibly in drug binding.

assay, thus bypassing the need for systematic MIC determination.

MDR and XDR strains (Pasca et al., 2010).

antimycobacterial agents.

et al., 2010).

fitness (M. R. Pasca, unpublished results).

concentrations used. Additional results suggested that BTZ efficacy is time- rather than dose-dependent (Makarov et al., 2009).

To find the target for BTZ, two independent genetic approaches were employed. Firstly, cosmids bearing DNA from *M. smegmatis* that confer increased resistance on *M. smegmatis* were identified and the region responsible was pinpointed by subcloning. This approach revealed that the *MSMEG\_6382* gene of *M. smegmatis* or its *M. tuberculosis* ortholog, *Rv3790*, mediated increased BTZ resistance. Secondly, *M. smegmatis*, *M. bovis* BCG, and *M. tuberculosis* mutants with a high-level of BTZ resistance were isolated and characterized. All these resistant mutants harbored missense mutations in the same gene (Makarov et al., 2009).

Biochemical studies showed that *Rv3790* and the neighboring gene *Rv3791* code for proteins that act in concert to catalyze the epimerization of decaprenylphosphoryl-D-ribose (DPR) to decaprenylphosphoryl-D-arabinose (DPA) (Mikusova et al., 2005), a precursor for arabinan synthesis without which a complete mycobacterial cell wall cannot be produced (see the paragraph below).

In all of the drug-resistant mutants we examined, the same codon of Rv3790 (or DprE1) was affected: cysteine at position 387 was replaced by serine or glycine codons, respectively. The BTZ resistance–determining region of *dprE1* was highly conserved in orthologous genes from various Actinobacteria, except that in a few cases cysteine (387 codon) was replaced by serine or alanine. The corresponding bacteria, *Mycobacterium avium* and *Mycobacterium aurum*, were found to be naturally resistant to BTZ thus supporting the identification of DprE1 as the BTZ target (Makarov et al., 2009; Figure 2).

Further corroboration was obtained biochemically by using membrane preparations from *M. smegmatis* to catalyze the epimerization reaction from radiolabeled DPR precursor, which was produced *in situ* from 5-phosphoribose diphosphate (Mikusova et al., 2005), in the presence or absence of BTZ. Addition of BTZ abolished the production of DPA from DPR. The reaction requires both DprE1 and DprE2. Furthermore, when the highly BTZ-resistant mutant of *M. bovis* BCG, or *M. smegmatis* were used as sources of enzymes, epimerization was no longer subjected to inhibition, thereby confirming identification of the BTZ target (Makarov et al., 2009).


Fig. 2. **Multiple alignment of the BTZ resistance–determining region in orthologs of**  *dprE1* **from various actinobacteria by ClustalW.** The cysteine (or correspondent amino acid) involved in the BTZ binding is highlighted in grey.

concentrations used. Additional results suggested that BTZ efficacy is time- rather than

To find the target for BTZ, two independent genetic approaches were employed. Firstly, cosmids bearing DNA from *M. smegmatis* that confer increased resistance on *M. smegmatis* were identified and the region responsible was pinpointed by subcloning. This approach revealed that the *MSMEG\_6382* gene of *M. smegmatis* or its *M. tuberculosis* ortholog, *Rv3790*, mediated increased BTZ resistance. Secondly, *M. smegmatis*, *M. bovis* BCG, and *M. tuberculosis* mutants with a high-level of BTZ resistance were isolated and characterized. All these resistant

Biochemical studies showed that *Rv3790* and the neighboring gene *Rv3791* code for proteins that act in concert to catalyze the epimerization of decaprenylphosphoryl-D-ribose (DPR) to decaprenylphosphoryl-D-arabinose (DPA) (Mikusova et al., 2005), a precursor for arabinan synthesis without which a complete mycobacterial cell wall cannot be produced (see the

In all of the drug-resistant mutants we examined, the same codon of Rv3790 (or DprE1) was affected: cysteine at position 387 was replaced by serine or glycine codons, respectively. The BTZ resistance–determining region of *dprE1* was highly conserved in orthologous genes from various Actinobacteria, except that in a few cases cysteine (387 codon) was replaced by serine or alanine. The corresponding bacteria, *Mycobacterium avium* and *Mycobacterium aurum*, were found to be naturally resistant to BTZ thus supporting the identification of

Further corroboration was obtained biochemically by using membrane preparations from *M. smegmatis* to catalyze the epimerization reaction from radiolabeled DPR precursor, which was produced *in situ* from 5-phosphoribose diphosphate (Mikusova et al., 2005), in the presence or absence of BTZ. Addition of BTZ abolished the production of DPA from DPR. The reaction requires both DprE1 and DprE2. Furthermore, when the highly BTZ-resistant mutant of *M. bovis* BCG, or *M. smegmatis* were used as sources of enzymes, epimerization was no longer subjected to inhibition, thereby confirming identification of the BTZ target

Fig. 2. **Multiple alignment of the BTZ resistance–determining region in orthologs of**  *dprE1* **from various actinobacteria by ClustalW.** The cysteine (or correspondent amino

mutants harbored missense mutations in the same gene (Makarov et al., 2009).

DprE1 as the BTZ target (Makarov et al., 2009; Figure 2).

acid) involved in the BTZ binding is highlighted in grey.

dose-dependent (Makarov et al., 2009).

paragraph below).

(Makarov et al., 2009).

In order to monitor the potential development of BTZ resistance, a total of 240 sensitive and multidrug-resistant *M. tuberculosis* clinical isolates from four European hospitals were surveyed for the presence of mutations in the *dprE1* gene and for BTZ susceptibility (Pasca et al., 2010).

The pharmaceutical industry usually estimates the likelihood of the development of resistance against a new drug by focusing on the mutation resistance rate, on the assumption that this rate is a major determinant of resistance development in clinical settings (Andersson, 2006). Therefore, drug targets for which the resistance mechanisms have the most negative effect on fitness are expected to show a low resistance development rate (Andersson, 2006). It is noteworthy that *in vitro M. tuberculosis* BTZ-resistant mutants were rare, arising at a frequency of 10-8 (Makarov et al., 2009) and they have not a good fitness (M. R. Pasca, unpublished results).

The *M. tuberculosis* clinical isolates (including MDR- and XDR-TB strains) from four different European hospitals were screened for mutations in the Cys387 codon of *dprE1* and for BTZ sensitivity. Seventy-eight *M. tuberculosis* clinical isolates came from the National Institute for Infectious Diseases (INMI) "L. Spallanzani" hospital in Rome, Italy; 118 strains were isolated at the Sondalo Division of the Valtellina and Valchiavenna, Italy, hospital authority; 32 clinical isolates were from the "Ambroise Paré" Hospital in Boulogne-Billancourt, France; and 12 strains were isolated at the "Central Institute of Tuberculosis" in Moscow, Russia. All strains were isolated between 2003 and 2009 and 1 was an XDR strain and 38 (15.8%) had an MDR phenotype. Moreover, 35 MDR strains were resistant to other first- and second-line drugs and they were sensitive to only a few drugs. Some *M. tuberculosis* clinical isolates were resistant to one or more drugs but did not meet the MDR definition (24.6%). Seven *M. tuberculosis* clinical strains were isolated from HIV-positive patients. The *dprE1* gene was amplified by PCR and sequenced from all clinical isolates. None of the *M. tuberculosis* isolates had mutations in the *dprE1* gene, and hence, these isolates were presumably sensitive to BTZ (Pasca et al., 2010). This result confirms that BTZ resistance mutations are not present in the strains of *M. tuberculosis* currently circulating.

From these results, it is reasonable to hypothesize that the cysteine residue has a fundamental role in BTZ sensitivity, possibly in drug binding.

To confirm this hypothesis, we showed that all the *M. tuberculosis* clinical isolates were sensitive to BTZ043, with values ranging from 0.75 to 30 ng/ml. This result confirms that BTZ043 is very active against both sensitive and resistant strains of *M. tuberculosis*, including MDR and XDR strains (Pasca et al., 2010).

These results have very important implications for future clinical trials. Specifically, it will be possible to perform an easy and rapid diagnostic test for BTZ resistance in clinical isolates simply by sequencing the *dprE1* gene around the Cys387 codon or by using a real time-PCR assay, thus bypassing the need for systematic MIC determination.

Given the previous results, the BTZs have been shown to be a new class of potent antimycobacterial agents.

Other information about the binding between the BTZs and their target came from Trefzer and collaborators that demonstrated that BTZs are activated in the bacterium by reduction

Fighting Against Resistant Strains: The Case of Benzothiazinones and Dinitrobenzamides 281

mutation led to the substitution of leucine at position 137 by proline, leading to the hypothesis that the resistance of this mutant could be due to a defective repressor (MSMEG\_6503), possibly causing over-expression of NfnB and, consequently, the reduction

Consistent with this hypothesis, the MIC of BTZ045, the amino derivative of BTZ043, for *M. smegmatis* was already known to be 0.5 g/ml *versus* 4–8 ng/ml of the original nitro

Moreover, 14 other spontaneous mutants, showing different levels of resistance (8–32X-MIC), were found to carry mutations in the *MSMEG\_6503* gene, including deletions and insertions. All the mutant strains were predicted to produce a truncated form of the protein. One of these mutants presented a mutation in the hypothetical repressor binding site

In order to verify the role of MSMEG\_6503 in *nfnB* regulation, MSMEG\_6503 proteins from *M. smegmatis* wild-type and from one of the mutants were purified and used in DNA binding assays. MSMEG\_6503 from *M. smegmatis* wild-type strain was able to bind and efficiently retard the *MSMEG\_6503-nfnB* intergenic region, while the mutant protein bound

High levels of *nfnB* expression were detected by Real-Time PCR in the *M. smegmatis* BTZ

To further confirm the direct role of NfnB in the BTZ resistance, an in-frame unmarked deletion was created in the *nfnB* gene and the *nfnB* strain was sensitive to BTZ (Manina et

Both wild-type *M. smegmatis* and one of the resistant mutants were evaluated for their ability to convert the nitro-compound to the amino-derivative, by high-pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC) analysis of culture media. The mutant transforms the nitro- to the amino-compound more efficiently and more rapidly compared with *M. smegmatis* wild-type

In order to assess the activity of the purified NfnB protein towards BTZ043, an indirect evaluation was initially performed, using an assay in which BTZ043 blocks the epimerization of DPR to DPA (Makarov et al., 2009). Recombinant NfnB enzyme was thus added to the assay mixtures to monitor DPA synthesis. When BTZ043 was pretreated with purified NfnB prior to addition to the reaction mixture, DPA was still formed, most likely due to the conversion of the active drug (BTZ043) to its inactive amino form (Manina et al.,

*M. tuberculosis* most probably lacks enzymes able to inactivate BTZ043 either in aerobic or anaerobic environment, consistent with the low MIC values of BTZ043 in *M. tuberculosis* and the fact that all the BTZ-resistant mutants isolated so far in this species harbored mutations

The crystal structure of NfnB was determined at 1.75 Å resolution. The structure of NfnB in complex with NADPH was obtained by the prior addition of the cofactor during crystallization, and was refined in the same crystallographic space group at 1.80 Å

of the BTZ nitro-molecule to its less active amino-derivative (Manina et al., 2010a).

compound (Makarov et al., 2009).

this region less efficiently (Manina et al., 2010a).

in the target gene *dprE1* (Manina et al., 2010a).

resolution (Manina et al., 2010a).

resistant mutants (Manina et al., 2010a).

strain (Manina et al., 2010a).

(Manina et al., 2010a).

al., 2010a).

2010a).

of an essential nitro group to a nitroso derivative, which then specifically reacts with a cysteine residue in the active site of DprE1 (Trefzer et al., 2010).

As early metabolic studies with bacteria or mice indicated that the BTZ nitro group could be reduced to an amino group, and as many antitubercular drugs are prodrugs that require activation by *M. tuberculosis*, the S and R enantiomers of the amino derivatives and the likely hydroxylamine intermediate were synthesized and tested for antimycobacterial activity *in vitro*. The amino and hydroxylamine derivatives were substantially less active (500- to 5000 fold) respect to the nitro form (Makarov et al., 2009).

In this context, another novel resistance mechanism to BTZs was described in *M. smegmatis* (Manina et al., 2010a). The over-expression of the nitroreductase NfnB leads to the inactivation of the drug by reduction of a critical nitro group to an amino group (Figure 3).

Fig. 3. **Nitroreduction of BTZ nitro form in amino form by NfnB nitroreductase.**

The direct involvement of NfnB in the inactivation of the lead compound BTZ043 was demonstrated by enzymology, microbiological assays and gene knockout experiments.

*M. smegmatis* resistant mutants which showed a low level of BTZ resistance (16X-MIC) were isolated. One of these mutants harbored neither mutations in *MSMEG\_6382* nor in *MSMEG\_6385*, the genes orthologous to *M. tuberculosis dprE1* and *dprE2*, respectively. In order to identify the gene responsible for the BTZ resistance phenotype, this mutant was transformed with a wild-type *M. smegmatis* cosmid library, and a selection for sensitivity to BTZ043 was carried out. A transformant colony characterized by a resistance decrease from 16X-MIC to 2X-MIC was isolated, and the correspondent cosmid responsible for restoration of BTZ043 sensitivity, was isolated and partially sequenced. Subcloning experiments of the cosmid were then performed and this led to the identification of a fragment responsible for the resistance containing the *MSMEG\_6503* gene, coding for a putative transcriptional regulator from the TetR family, and the *MSMEG\_6505* gene, coding for NfnB enzyme due to its 35% sequence identity to the *E. coli* NfnB/NfsB nitroreductase. The sequence analysis revealed no mutations in the *nfnB* gene, but a point mutation in *MSMEG\_6503*. This

of an essential nitro group to a nitroso derivative, which then specifically reacts with a

As early metabolic studies with bacteria or mice indicated that the BTZ nitro group could be reduced to an amino group, and as many antitubercular drugs are prodrugs that require activation by *M. tuberculosis*, the S and R enantiomers of the amino derivatives and the likely hydroxylamine intermediate were synthesized and tested for antimycobacterial activity *in vitro*. The amino and hydroxylamine derivatives were substantially less active (500- to 5000-

In this context, another novel resistance mechanism to BTZs was described in *M. smegmatis* (Manina et al., 2010a). The over-expression of the nitroreductase NfnB leads to the inactivation of the drug by reduction of a critical nitro group to an amino group (Figure 3).

Fig. 3. **Nitroreduction of BTZ nitro form in amino form by NfnB nitroreductase.**

The direct involvement of NfnB in the inactivation of the lead compound BTZ043 was demonstrated by enzymology, microbiological assays and gene knockout experiments.

*M. smegmatis* resistant mutants which showed a low level of BTZ resistance (16X-MIC) were isolated. One of these mutants harbored neither mutations in *MSMEG\_6382* nor in *MSMEG\_6385*, the genes orthologous to *M. tuberculosis dprE1* and *dprE2*, respectively. In order to identify the gene responsible for the BTZ resistance phenotype, this mutant was transformed with a wild-type *M. smegmatis* cosmid library, and a selection for sensitivity to BTZ043 was carried out. A transformant colony characterized by a resistance decrease from 16X-MIC to 2X-MIC was isolated, and the correspondent cosmid responsible for restoration of BTZ043 sensitivity, was isolated and partially sequenced. Subcloning experiments of the cosmid were then performed and this led to the identification of a fragment responsible for the resistance containing the *MSMEG\_6503* gene, coding for a putative transcriptional regulator from the TetR family, and the *MSMEG\_6505* gene, coding for NfnB enzyme due to its 35% sequence identity to the *E. coli* NfnB/NfsB nitroreductase. The sequence analysis revealed no mutations in the *nfnB* gene, but a point mutation in *MSMEG\_6503*. This

cysteine residue in the active site of DprE1 (Trefzer et al., 2010).

fold) respect to the nitro form (Makarov et al., 2009).

mutation led to the substitution of leucine at position 137 by proline, leading to the hypothesis that the resistance of this mutant could be due to a defective repressor (MSMEG\_6503), possibly causing over-expression of NfnB and, consequently, the reduction of the BTZ nitro-molecule to its less active amino-derivative (Manina et al., 2010a).

Consistent with this hypothesis, the MIC of BTZ045, the amino derivative of BTZ043, for *M. smegmatis* was already known to be 0.5 g/ml *versus* 4–8 ng/ml of the original nitro compound (Makarov et al., 2009).

Moreover, 14 other spontaneous mutants, showing different levels of resistance (8–32X-MIC), were found to carry mutations in the *MSMEG\_6503* gene, including deletions and insertions. All the mutant strains were predicted to produce a truncated form of the protein. One of these mutants presented a mutation in the hypothetical repressor binding site (Manina et al., 2010a).

In order to verify the role of MSMEG\_6503 in *nfnB* regulation, MSMEG\_6503 proteins from *M. smegmatis* wild-type and from one of the mutants were purified and used in DNA binding assays. MSMEG\_6503 from *M. smegmatis* wild-type strain was able to bind and efficiently retard the *MSMEG\_6503-nfnB* intergenic region, while the mutant protein bound this region less efficiently (Manina et al., 2010a).

High levels of *nfnB* expression were detected by Real-Time PCR in the *M. smegmatis* BTZ resistant mutants (Manina et al., 2010a).

To further confirm the direct role of NfnB in the BTZ resistance, an in-frame unmarked deletion was created in the *nfnB* gene and the *nfnB* strain was sensitive to BTZ (Manina et al., 2010a).

Both wild-type *M. smegmatis* and one of the resistant mutants were evaluated for their ability to convert the nitro-compound to the amino-derivative, by high-pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC) analysis of culture media. The mutant transforms the nitro- to the amino-compound more efficiently and more rapidly compared with *M. smegmatis* wild-type strain (Manina et al., 2010a).

In order to assess the activity of the purified NfnB protein towards BTZ043, an indirect evaluation was initially performed, using an assay in which BTZ043 blocks the epimerization of DPR to DPA (Makarov et al., 2009). Recombinant NfnB enzyme was thus added to the assay mixtures to monitor DPA synthesis. When BTZ043 was pretreated with purified NfnB prior to addition to the reaction mixture, DPA was still formed, most likely due to the conversion of the active drug (BTZ043) to its inactive amino form (Manina et al., 2010a).

*M. tuberculosis* most probably lacks enzymes able to inactivate BTZ043 either in aerobic or anaerobic environment, consistent with the low MIC values of BTZ043 in *M. tuberculosis* and the fact that all the BTZ-resistant mutants isolated so far in this species harbored mutations in the target gene *dprE1* (Manina et al., 2010a).

The crystal structure of NfnB was determined at 1.75 Å resolution. The structure of NfnB in complex with NADPH was obtained by the prior addition of the cofactor during crystallization, and was refined in the same crystallographic space group at 1.80 Å resolution (Manina et al., 2010a).

Fighting Against Resistant Strains: The Case of Benzothiazinones and Dinitrobenzamides 283

Fig. 4. **Chemical structure of dinitrobenzamide compounds.** R1 can be either a nitro (-NO2), an amino (-NH2), a hydroxylamine (-NHOH) or a hydrogen (-H) group, whereas R2 stands

This chemical library was first screened at a single concentration. 486 fully active hits were then confirmed by means of serial dilution experiments. More than one quarter of the hits (135 hits) had an MIC less than 5 mM, and 8% had a MIC below 1 mM, which is equivalent

The largest cluster had 69 members with an isonicotinohydrazide moiety similar to that of isoniazid, used as a positive reference in the assay. The second largest cluster of 24 derivatives shares a common benzamide scaffold. A series of related derivatives was synthesized for further studies. To identify the chemical substituents necessary for benzamide antibacterial activity, over 155 additional derivatives were synthesized and their structure-activity relationship was analyzed using both intracellular assay and the *in vitro* growth assay. The most potent compounds exhibited substitutions of the benzene moiety with a nitro group at positions 3 and 5. The reduction of one nitro- to hydroxylamine and amino groups led to totally inactive compounds. In contrast, derivatives with an Nsubstitution by benzyloxy-ethyl or by phenoxy-ethyl showed enhanced activity with an MIC below 0.2 mM. More importantly, cyclic-benzamides had an MIC below 80 nM in the *in vitro* assay. Moreover, substitution of the benzyloxy moiety by a chlorine- or fluorine atoms at position 3 led to increased potency in both assays in contrast to carboxyl substitutions. Two compounds, N-(2-(4-methoxyphenoxy) ethyl)-3,5-dinitrobenzamide (DNB1) and N-(2- (benzyloxy) ethyl)-3,5-dinitrobenzamide (DNB2) were selected for the characterization. No cell toxicity was noted for these compounds using conventional cytotoxicity assays of uninfected cells, indicating that this assay can predict the cytotoxicity. Analysis of the broad antimicrobial spectrum revealed that the effect of these dinitrobenzamide derivatives was mainly restricted to Actinomycetes. Of particular importance, DNB1 and DNB2 were also highly active against MDR and XDR clinical isolates. The bactericidal effect on *M. tuberculosis* of DNB1 and DNB2 was found to be time-dependent and to require several days to reach bacterial clearance, implying that they could interfere with *de novo* mycobacterial component biosynthesis. This is further corroborated by the fact that the DNB compounds

lost their activity in a non-replicating *M. tuberculosis* system (Christophe et al., 2009).

In a preliminary experiment using the acute mouse model of *M. tuberculosis*, a one log reduction of the colony forming unit in the lungs of DNB treated animals compared to non-

for different aromatic substituents.

to that of isoniazid (Christophe et al., 2009).

It was shown that a common amino acid stretch between NfnB and DprE1 is likely to be essential for the interaction with BTZ. An amino acid sequence alignment shows a common amino acid stretch of 30 amino acids between NfnB (residues 86–115) and DprE1 (residues 386–417), displaying 46% sequence identity (59% similarity). It is noteworthy that this amino acid stretch is located at the C-terminal end of DprE1, the same region in which spontaneous mutations conferring resistance to BTZ were identified (Makarov et al., 2009), suggesting that this polypeptide portion might also play a key role in defining the relative specificity of NfnB towards the nitromolecules from the BTZ class. Docking analysis of NfnB-BTZ was performed in order to understand their interaction and the mechanism of nitroreduction (Manina et al., 2010a).

However, it has also been observed that the nitro-BTZ compounds are transformed into the corresponding amino-derivatives not only in *M. smegmatis* cultures overexpressing NfnB, but also in blood and urine from treated mice (V. Makarov, unpublished data), strongly suggesting that one or more nitroreductases, either mammalian or from the intestinal microbial flora, could carry out such a conversion. Indeed, it is well known that nitroaromatic compounds can be converted into their metabolites in the intestine, by the action of several microbial nitroreductases (Roldán et al., 2008).

Although *M. tuberculosis* seems to lack nitroreductases able to inactivate these drugs, this finding is useful for the design of new BTZ molecules or new antitubercular drugs, which may be more effective *in vivo*.

## **3. Dinitrobenzamides**

Another new class of potent antitubercular drugs, the dinitrobenzamide derivatives (DNBs) (Figure 4), was identified through a screening of chemicals which interfere with *M. tuberculosis* replication within macrophages (Christophe et al., 2009). The most active compounds among DNBs exhibited substitutions of the benzene moiety with a nitro group at positions 3 and 5. The two major compounds from this series, [N-(2-(4-methoxyphenoxy) ethyl)-3,5-dinitrobenzamide] and [N-(2-(benzyloxy) ethyl)-3,5-dinitrobenzamide], named DNB1 and DNB2 respectively, were also highly active against *M. tuberculosis* MDR and XDR strains (Christophe et al., 2009; Figure 4).

To find the DNB derivatives, a new phenotypic cell-based assay for high throughput screening of chemical compounds that interfere with the replication of *M. tuberculosis* within macrophages was developed. This assay is based on the use of automated confocal fluorescent microscopy to monitor intracellular growth of green fluorescent proteinexpressing *M. tuberculosis* H37Rv in Raw264.7 macrophages (Christophe et al., 2009).

A screening of a library of 56,984 small molecules led to the identification of 135 active compounds with potent intracellular anti-mycobacterial efficacy and no host cell toxicity. Among these, the DNB derivatives showed high activity against *M. tuberculosis*. The assay was set-up for the high throughput screening of large chemical libraries in 384-well format. To set up the optimal conditions of *M. tuberculosis* infection, Raw264.7 macrophages were first infected with mycobacteria that constitutively express green fluorescent protein using different multiplicities of infection followed by kinetic analysis of intracellular bacterial growth. Confocal images of live samples were acquired using an automated confocal microscope (OperaTM) over 7 days (Christophe et al., 2009).

It was shown that a common amino acid stretch between NfnB and DprE1 is likely to be essential for the interaction with BTZ. An amino acid sequence alignment shows a common amino acid stretch of 30 amino acids between NfnB (residues 86–115) and DprE1 (residues 386–417), displaying 46% sequence identity (59% similarity). It is noteworthy that this amino acid stretch is located at the C-terminal end of DprE1, the same region in which spontaneous mutations conferring resistance to BTZ were identified (Makarov et al., 2009), suggesting that this polypeptide portion might also play a key role in defining the relative specificity of NfnB towards the nitromolecules from the BTZ class. Docking analysis of NfnB-BTZ was performed in order to understand their interaction and the mechanism of nitroreduction

However, it has also been observed that the nitro-BTZ compounds are transformed into the corresponding amino-derivatives not only in *M. smegmatis* cultures overexpressing NfnB, but also in blood and urine from treated mice (V. Makarov, unpublished data), strongly suggesting that one or more nitroreductases, either mammalian or from the intestinal microbial flora, could carry out such a conversion. Indeed, it is well known that nitroaromatic compounds can be converted into their metabolites in the intestine, by the

Although *M. tuberculosis* seems to lack nitroreductases able to inactivate these drugs, this finding is useful for the design of new BTZ molecules or new antitubercular drugs, which

Another new class of potent antitubercular drugs, the dinitrobenzamide derivatives (DNBs) (Figure 4), was identified through a screening of chemicals which interfere with *M. tuberculosis* replication within macrophages (Christophe et al., 2009). The most active compounds among DNBs exhibited substitutions of the benzene moiety with a nitro group at positions 3 and 5. The two major compounds from this series, [N-(2-(4-methoxyphenoxy) ethyl)-3,5-dinitrobenzamide] and [N-(2-(benzyloxy) ethyl)-3,5-dinitrobenzamide], named DNB1 and DNB2 respectively, were also highly active against *M. tuberculosis* MDR and XDR

To find the DNB derivatives, a new phenotypic cell-based assay for high throughput screening of chemical compounds that interfere with the replication of *M. tuberculosis* within macrophages was developed. This assay is based on the use of automated confocal fluorescent microscopy to monitor intracellular growth of green fluorescent proteinexpressing *M. tuberculosis* H37Rv in Raw264.7 macrophages (Christophe et al., 2009).

A screening of a library of 56,984 small molecules led to the identification of 135 active compounds with potent intracellular anti-mycobacterial efficacy and no host cell toxicity. Among these, the DNB derivatives showed high activity against *M. tuberculosis*. The assay was set-up for the high throughput screening of large chemical libraries in 384-well format. To set up the optimal conditions of *M. tuberculosis* infection, Raw264.7 macrophages were first infected with mycobacteria that constitutively express green fluorescent protein using different multiplicities of infection followed by kinetic analysis of intracellular bacterial growth. Confocal images of live samples were acquired using an automated confocal

action of several microbial nitroreductases (Roldán et al., 2008).

(Manina et al., 2010a).

may be more effective *in vivo*.

strains (Christophe et al., 2009; Figure 4).

microscope (OperaTM) over 7 days (Christophe et al., 2009).

**3. Dinitrobenzamides** 

Fig. 4. **Chemical structure of dinitrobenzamide compounds.** R1 can be either a nitro (-NO2), an amino (-NH2), a hydroxylamine (-NHOH) or a hydrogen (-H) group, whereas R2 stands for different aromatic substituents.

This chemical library was first screened at a single concentration. 486 fully active hits were then confirmed by means of serial dilution experiments. More than one quarter of the hits (135 hits) had an MIC less than 5 mM, and 8% had a MIC below 1 mM, which is equivalent to that of isoniazid (Christophe et al., 2009).

The largest cluster had 69 members with an isonicotinohydrazide moiety similar to that of isoniazid, used as a positive reference in the assay. The second largest cluster of 24 derivatives shares a common benzamide scaffold. A series of related derivatives was synthesized for further studies. To identify the chemical substituents necessary for benzamide antibacterial activity, over 155 additional derivatives were synthesized and their structure-activity relationship was analyzed using both intracellular assay and the *in vitro* growth assay. The most potent compounds exhibited substitutions of the benzene moiety with a nitro group at positions 3 and 5. The reduction of one nitro- to hydroxylamine and amino groups led to totally inactive compounds. In contrast, derivatives with an Nsubstitution by benzyloxy-ethyl or by phenoxy-ethyl showed enhanced activity with an MIC below 0.2 mM. More importantly, cyclic-benzamides had an MIC below 80 nM in the *in vitro* assay. Moreover, substitution of the benzyloxy moiety by a chlorine- or fluorine atoms at position 3 led to increased potency in both assays in contrast to carboxyl substitutions. Two compounds, N-(2-(4-methoxyphenoxy) ethyl)-3,5-dinitrobenzamide (DNB1) and N-(2- (benzyloxy) ethyl)-3,5-dinitrobenzamide (DNB2) were selected for the characterization. No cell toxicity was noted for these compounds using conventional cytotoxicity assays of uninfected cells, indicating that this assay can predict the cytotoxicity. Analysis of the broad antimicrobial spectrum revealed that the effect of these dinitrobenzamide derivatives was mainly restricted to Actinomycetes. Of particular importance, DNB1 and DNB2 were also highly active against MDR and XDR clinical isolates. The bactericidal effect on *M. tuberculosis* of DNB1 and DNB2 was found to be time-dependent and to require several days to reach bacterial clearance, implying that they could interfere with *de novo* mycobacterial component biosynthesis. This is further corroborated by the fact that the DNB compounds lost their activity in a non-replicating *M. tuberculosis* system (Christophe et al., 2009).

In a preliminary experiment using the acute mouse model of *M. tuberculosis*, a one log reduction of the colony forming unit in the lungs of DNB treated animals compared to non-

Fighting Against Resistant Strains: The Case of Benzothiazinones and Dinitrobenzamides 285

These enzymes utilize the unusual sugar decaprenylphosphoryl-*D*-arabinose (DPA, Figure 5) as the only donor of Ara*f* residues in both mycobacteria and corynebacteria (Meniche et al., 2008). It is noteworthy that without DPA, a complete mycobacterial cell wall cannot be produced. DPA is synthesized from phosphoribose diphosphate through a series of three successive reactions (Meniche et al., 2008): (i) transfer of phosphoribose diphosphate to decaprenyl phosphate to form decaprenylphosphoryl-5-phosphoribose, (ii) removal of the 5′ phosphate in order to give decaprenylphosphoryl-*D*-ribose (DPR, Figure 5), and (iii) epimerization of DPR into DPA, which likely occurs *via* a sequential oxidation-reduction mechanism involving an intermediate (DPX, Figure 5), which is a product of DPR oxidation and a precursor of DPA. Although not unambiguously identified, DPX is most probably a

decaprenylphosphoryl-2-keto-β-D-erythro-pentofuranose (Figure 5).

Fig. 5. **The enzymatic reaction catalyzed by decaprenylphosphoryl--D-ribose 2'** 

decaprenylphosphoryl-*D*-ribose, while DPX is the intermediate decaprenylphospho-2-

The epimerization reaction is reported in Figure 5. It is catalyzed by the decaprenylphospho-ribose 2'-epimerase, a heteromeric enzyme composed of two types of polypeptides encoded by the *Rv3790* (*dprE1*) and *Rv3791* (*dprE2*) genes, respectively (Wolucka, 2008; Mikusova et al., 2005). The membrane-associated enzymes DprE1 and DprE2 have been suggested to act as decaprenylphosphoryl-β-D-ribose oxidase and decaprenylphosphoryl-D-2-keto erythro pentose reductase, respectively (Makarov et al., 2009). It is noteworthy that

**epimerase (composed by DprE1 and DprE2) is reported.** DPR indicates

ketofuranose and DPA the decaprenylphosphoryl-*D*-arabinose.

treated controls was observed after a three week daily treatment with 30 mg/kg/day following an intranasal infection.

To gain insight into the possible targets of dinitrobenzamides, the effect of DNB1 and DNB2 on the lipid composition of the cell envelope of *M. tuberculosis* was investigated; no effects on the biosynthesis of fatty acids, mycolic acids and/or other lipids were noted. By contrast, DNB1 and DNB2 showed a clear-cut effect on the synthesis of the arabinan domains of arabinogalactan and lipoarabinomannan. DPA is the only known arabinofuranose (Ara*f*) donor in the biogenesis of arabinogalactan and lipoarabinomannan in mycobacteria and is thus an essential precursor (Wolucka, 2008). The effects of DNB in the inhibition of the synthesis of DPA were tested. Analyses revealed complete inhibition of DPA formation in the DNB-treated extracts, concurrent with the accumulation of DPR, indicating that the target of DNB inhibitors could be the heteromeric decaprenylphospho-ribose epimerase encoded by the *dprE1*/*dprE2* genes in *M. tuberculosis* H37Rv, the same target of benzothiazinones (Christophe et al., 2009; Makarov et al., 2009). Moreover BTZ resistant mutants of *M. smegmatis* and *M. bovis* BCG having a mutation in *dprE1* gene, were also resistant to DNB inhibitors.

Recently it has been demonstrated that the DNB and the BTZ have not only the same target, but also the same mechanisms of resistance (M.R. Pasca, unpublished data).

## **4. The decaprenyl-phosphoribose 2'-epimerase**

Mycobacteria cell envelope is a peculiar characteristic of these microorganisms. It forms an efficient permeability barrier, playing a crucial role in intrinsic drug resistance as well as in macrophage survival under stress conditions. Several fundamental antitubercular drugs, such as isoniazid and ethambutol, target enzymes involved in some specific cell-wall biosynthetic pathways (Barry et al., 2007). Furthermore the mycobacterial cell envelope is still considered an outstanding cellular source for target discovery.

The mycobacterial cell envelope is composed of three main portions. From the external side towards the cytoplasmic membrane we find: a highly impermeable layer of mycolic acids (long-chain (C70–C90) -branched, -hydroxy fatty acids), the complex polysaccharide arabinogalactan, and a peptidoglycan layer. Arabinogalactan is covalently attached to peptidoglycan by a phosphodiester linkage and is esterified by mycolic acids. The entire complex is named mycolyl-arabinogalactan–peptidoglycan (Alderwick et al., 2007), and represents a strong protective barrier for the pathogen. This complex also keeps a dynamic trait, useful for facing different environmental conditions. Chemical analysis of the cell envelope composition has also revealed the presence of diverse noncovalently bound lipids (such as phosphatidyl-myo-inositol mannosides), lipopolysaccharides (such as lipoarabinomannans), mannose-capped lipoarabinomannans, poly-L-glutamate–glutamine polymers, enzymes and other proteins. In slow-growing mycobacterial species, such as *M. tuberculosis*, proteins and polysaccharides are present in the outermost stratum known as the capsule (Umesiri et al., 2010).

Synthesis of arabinan domain of arabinogalactan derives from sequential additions of Ara*f* residues to the galactan domain, while lipoarabinogalactan originates from the addition of Ara*f* units on the mannan domain by specialized arabinosyltransferases (Wolucka, 2008).

treated controls was observed after a three week daily treatment with 30 mg/kg/day

To gain insight into the possible targets of dinitrobenzamides, the effect of DNB1 and DNB2 on the lipid composition of the cell envelope of *M. tuberculosis* was investigated; no effects on the biosynthesis of fatty acids, mycolic acids and/or other lipids were noted. By contrast, DNB1 and DNB2 showed a clear-cut effect on the synthesis of the arabinan domains of arabinogalactan and lipoarabinomannan. DPA is the only known arabinofuranose (Ara*f*) donor in the biogenesis of arabinogalactan and lipoarabinomannan in mycobacteria and is thus an essential precursor (Wolucka, 2008). The effects of DNB in the inhibition of the synthesis of DPA were tested. Analyses revealed complete inhibition of DPA formation in the DNB-treated extracts, concurrent with the accumulation of DPR, indicating that the target of DNB inhibitors could be the heteromeric decaprenylphospho-ribose epimerase encoded by the *dprE1*/*dprE2* genes in *M. tuberculosis* H37Rv, the same target of benzothiazinones (Christophe et al., 2009; Makarov et al., 2009). Moreover BTZ resistant mutants of *M. smegmatis* and *M. bovis* BCG having a mutation in *dprE1* gene, were also

Recently it has been demonstrated that the DNB and the BTZ have not only the same target,

Mycobacteria cell envelope is a peculiar characteristic of these microorganisms. It forms an efficient permeability barrier, playing a crucial role in intrinsic drug resistance as well as in macrophage survival under stress conditions. Several fundamental antitubercular drugs, such as isoniazid and ethambutol, target enzymes involved in some specific cell-wall biosynthetic pathways (Barry et al., 2007). Furthermore the mycobacterial cell envelope is

The mycobacterial cell envelope is composed of three main portions. From the external side towards the cytoplasmic membrane we find: a highly impermeable layer of mycolic acids (long-chain (C70–C90) -branched, -hydroxy fatty acids), the complex polysaccharide arabinogalactan, and a peptidoglycan layer. Arabinogalactan is covalently attached to peptidoglycan by a phosphodiester linkage and is esterified by mycolic acids. The entire complex is named mycolyl-arabinogalactan–peptidoglycan (Alderwick et al., 2007), and represents a strong protective barrier for the pathogen. This complex also keeps a dynamic trait, useful for facing different environmental conditions. Chemical analysis of the cell envelope composition has also revealed the presence of diverse noncovalently bound lipids (such as phosphatidyl-myo-inositol mannosides), lipopolysaccharides (such as lipoarabinomannans), mannose-capped lipoarabinomannans, poly-L-glutamate–glutamine polymers, enzymes and other proteins. In slow-growing mycobacterial species, such as *M. tuberculosis*, proteins and polysaccharides are present in the outermost stratum known as the

Synthesis of arabinan domain of arabinogalactan derives from sequential additions of Ara*f* residues to the galactan domain, while lipoarabinogalactan originates from the addition of Ara*f* units on the mannan domain by specialized arabinosyltransferases (Wolucka, 2008).

but also the same mechanisms of resistance (M.R. Pasca, unpublished data).

**4. The decaprenyl-phosphoribose 2'-epimerase** 

still considered an outstanding cellular source for target discovery.

following an intranasal infection.

resistant to DNB inhibitors.

capsule (Umesiri et al., 2010).

These enzymes utilize the unusual sugar decaprenylphosphoryl-*D*-arabinose (DPA, Figure 5) as the only donor of Ara*f* residues in both mycobacteria and corynebacteria (Meniche et al., 2008). It is noteworthy that without DPA, a complete mycobacterial cell wall cannot be produced. DPA is synthesized from phosphoribose diphosphate through a series of three successive reactions (Meniche et al., 2008): (i) transfer of phosphoribose diphosphate to decaprenyl phosphate to form decaprenylphosphoryl-5-phosphoribose, (ii) removal of the 5′ phosphate in order to give decaprenylphosphoryl-*D*-ribose (DPR, Figure 5), and (iii) epimerization of DPR into DPA, which likely occurs *via* a sequential oxidation-reduction mechanism involving an intermediate (DPX, Figure 5), which is a product of DPR oxidation and a precursor of DPA. Although not unambiguously identified, DPX is most probably a decaprenylphosphoryl-2-keto-β-D-erythro-pentofuranose (Figure 5).

Fig. 5. **The enzymatic reaction catalyzed by decaprenylphosphoryl--D-ribose 2' epimerase (composed by DprE1 and DprE2) is reported.** DPR indicates decaprenylphosphoryl-*D*-ribose, while DPX is the intermediate decaprenylphospho-2 ketofuranose and DPA the decaprenylphosphoryl-*D*-arabinose.

The epimerization reaction is reported in Figure 5. It is catalyzed by the decaprenylphospho-ribose 2'-epimerase, a heteromeric enzyme composed of two types of polypeptides encoded by the *Rv3790* (*dprE1*) and *Rv3791* (*dprE2*) genes, respectively (Wolucka, 2008; Mikusova et al., 2005). The membrane-associated enzymes DprE1 and DprE2 have been suggested to act as decaprenylphosphoryl-β-D-ribose oxidase and decaprenylphosphoryl-D-2-keto erythro pentose reductase, respectively (Makarov et al., 2009). It is noteworthy that

Fighting Against Resistant Strains: The Case of Benzothiazinones and Dinitrobenzamides 287

mimicking decaprenylphosphoryl-*D*-arabinose, as possible inhibitors of cell wall biosynthesis in mycobacteria (Ayers et al., 2009). They demonstrated a low to moderate anti-

In summary, DprE1, as well as its orthologs, are not only optimal targets for benzothiazinones, dinitrobenzamides and the lastly described benzoquinoxalines (Makarov et al., 2009; Christophe et al., 2009; Magnet et al., 2010), but also promising targets for the discovery of new molecules in treating infections caused by *M. tuberculosis*, *Mycobacterium* 

At present, a fundamental goal is the production of large amounts of soluble DprE1 protein in order to develop an enzymatic assay suitable for high throughput screenings and to solve the DprE1 structure to design new molecules affecting the arabinogalactan biosynthesis.

The inexorable rise in cases of tuberculosis worldwide highlights the need for new drugs and, in particular, for those that can shorten the duration of treatment. Recently, two new promising antitubercular drugs were developed (Makarov et al., 2009; Christophe et al., 2009). Both these drugs have the same cellular target, the DprE1 of *M. tuberculosis* (Manina et al., 2010b). The preclinical development program of benzothiazinone lead (BTZ043) has

Moreover, another class of antitubercular drugs has been shown to have DprE1 as target, the

We thank the European Commission for support (VI Framework, contract N. LSHP-CT

Alderwick, L. J.; Birch, H. L.; Mishra, A. K.; Eggeling, L. & Besra, G. S. (2007). Structure,

Andersson, D. I. (2006). The biological cost of mutational antibiotic resistance: any practical

Ayers, B.; Long, H.; Sim, E.; Smellie, I. A.; Wilkinson, B. L. & Fairbanks, A. J. Stereoselective

Barry, C. E.; Crick, D. C. & McNeil, M. R. (2007). Targeting the formation of the cell wall core

function and biosynthesis of the *Mycobacterium tuberculosis* cell wall: arabinogalactan and lipoarabinomannan assembly with a view to discovering new drug targets. *Biochemical Society Transactions*, Vol. 35, No. Pt 5, (November 2007),

conclusions? *Current opinion in microbiology*, Vol. 9, no. 5, (October 2006), pp. 461–

synthesis of beta-arabino glycosyl sulfones as potential inhibitors of mycobacterial cell wall biosynthesis. *Carbohydrate Research*, Vol. 344, No. 6, (April 2009), pp. 739-

of *Mycobacterium tuberculosis*. *Infectious Disorders Drug Targets*, Vo. 7, No. 2, (June

This highlights the vulnerability of DprE1 and its importance as an antitubercular target.

mycobacterial activity, which is strongly dependent on alkyl chain length.

*leprae*, *Nocardia* spp., *Rhodococcus* spp., and *Corynebacterium* spp.

already begun and this class of drugs is very promising.

2005- 018923 and VII Framework, contract N. 260872).

pp. 1325-1328, ISSN 0300-5127.

2007), pp. 182-202, ISSN 1871-5265.

465, ISSN 1369-5274.

746, ISSN 0008-6215.

benzoquinoxalines (Magnet et al., 2010).

**6. Acknowledgment** 

**7. References** 

**5. Conclusion** 

for epimerase activity, a simultaneous expression of both polypeptides is required (Mikusova et al., 2005).

Little is known about the decaprenyl-phosphoribose 2'-epimerase. The DprE1 protein contains a FAD-binding N-terminal and a C-terminal D-arabinono-1,4-lactone oxidase-like enzyme domains (Wolucka, 2008). What is evident now, however, is that the decaprenylphosphoribose 2'-epimerase enzyme is a very important and authentic validated target for antitubercular drugs, being the target for at least three different classes of antitubercular drugs, namely benzothiazinones, dinitrobenzamides, and benzoquinoxalines whose lead compound is VI-9376, a molecule structurally related to benzothiazinones (Makarov et al., 2009; Christophe et al., 2009; Magnet et al., 2010).

Both the *dprE1* and *dprE2* genes were predicted to be essential by Himar1-based transposon mutagenesis in *M. tuberculosis* H37Rv (Sassetti et al., 2003), thus validating both enzymes as targets for drug development. Moreover, recently the construction of a conditional gene knockout strain targeting the ortholog of *dprE1* in *M. smegmatis*, *MSMEG\_6382*, has been reported (Crellin et al., 2011). Disruption of the chromosomal copy of *MSMEG\_6382* was only possible in the presence of a plasmid-encoded copy of *MSMEG\_6382*. Curing of this ''rescue'' plasmid from the bacterial population resulted in a cessation of growth, further demonstrating gene essentiality. This study provides the first direct experimental evidence for the essentiality of DprE1 in mycobacteria. Moreover, the essentiality of DprE1 in *M. smegmatis*, combined with its conservation in all sequenced mycobacterial genomes, suggests that decaprenylphosphoryl-*D*-arabinose synthesis is essential in all mycobacteria (Crellin et al., 2011). Overall, this study further validates DprE1 as a promising target for new anti-mycobacterial drugs.

Although many potential drug targets have been already identified, greater efforts are required in target validation to properly show their essentiality for bacterial growth and survival (Williams and Duncan, 2007). A rational antibiotic design strategy should aim to identify targets for which the resistance mechanism has the most negative effect on fitness, as in the case of the DprE1 enzyme. In fact, our data suggest that DprE1 is an optimal target also for MDR- and XDR-TB strains. The treatment of these strains is difficult if not impossible nowadays and could instead be defeated by a drug targeting *dprE1* gene product. The disruption of this essential ring in the construction of the mycobacterial cell wall makes the pathogen weak and completely unable to survive in a hostile environment, such as the macrophage. Moreover, decaprenylphosphoryl-*D*-arabinose is the only known Ara*f* donor in the biogenesis of arabinogalactan and lipoarabinomannan in mycobacteria and is thus an essential precursor.

It is worth mentioning that decaprenylphosphoryl-*D*-arabinose is a lead molecule for the design of substrates' analogs for mycobacterial arabinosyltransferases and of new inhibitors (Wolucka, 2008). Since 2004, the synthesis of decaprenylphosphoryl-*D*-arabinose analogs as antitubercular agents has been performed. Even if these molecules inhibit mycobacterial growth, their effect was not satisfactory (Centrone and Lowary, 2004). Other efforts have been made by researchers in order to interfere with arabinogalactan and lipoarabinomannan biosynthesis. Indeed, in 2009 Pathak and co-workers reported the synthesis of modified Ara*f* disaccharides as substrates and inhibitors of *M. tuberculosis* arabinosyltransferases (Pathak et al., 2009). Furthermore, Ayers and collaborators synthesized β-arabino glycosyl sulfones, mimicking decaprenylphosphoryl-*D*-arabinose, as possible inhibitors of cell wall biosynthesis in mycobacteria (Ayers et al., 2009). They demonstrated a low to moderate antimycobacterial activity, which is strongly dependent on alkyl chain length.

In summary, DprE1, as well as its orthologs, are not only optimal targets for benzothiazinones, dinitrobenzamides and the lastly described benzoquinoxalines (Makarov et al., 2009; Christophe et al., 2009; Magnet et al., 2010), but also promising targets for the discovery of new molecules in treating infections caused by *M. tuberculosis*, *Mycobacterium leprae*, *Nocardia* spp., *Rhodococcus* spp., and *Corynebacterium* spp.

At present, a fundamental goal is the production of large amounts of soluble DprE1 protein in order to develop an enzymatic assay suitable for high throughput screenings and to solve the DprE1 structure to design new molecules affecting the arabinogalactan biosynthesis.

## **5. Conclusion**

286 Understanding Tuberculosis – New Approaches to Fighting Against Drug Resistance

for epimerase activity, a simultaneous expression of both polypeptides is required

Little is known about the decaprenyl-phosphoribose 2'-epimerase. The DprE1 protein contains a FAD-binding N-terminal and a C-terminal D-arabinono-1,4-lactone oxidase-like enzyme domains (Wolucka, 2008). What is evident now, however, is that the decaprenylphosphoribose 2'-epimerase enzyme is a very important and authentic validated target for antitubercular drugs, being the target for at least three different classes of antitubercular drugs, namely benzothiazinones, dinitrobenzamides, and benzoquinoxalines whose lead compound is VI-9376, a molecule structurally related to benzothiazinones (Makarov et al.,

Both the *dprE1* and *dprE2* genes were predicted to be essential by Himar1-based transposon mutagenesis in *M. tuberculosis* H37Rv (Sassetti et al., 2003), thus validating both enzymes as targets for drug development. Moreover, recently the construction of a conditional gene knockout strain targeting the ortholog of *dprE1* in *M. smegmatis*, *MSMEG\_6382*, has been reported (Crellin et al., 2011). Disruption of the chromosomal copy of *MSMEG\_6382* was only possible in the presence of a plasmid-encoded copy of *MSMEG\_6382*. Curing of this ''rescue'' plasmid from the bacterial population resulted in a cessation of growth, further demonstrating gene essentiality. This study provides the first direct experimental evidence for the essentiality of DprE1 in mycobacteria. Moreover, the essentiality of DprE1 in *M. smegmatis*, combined with its conservation in all sequenced mycobacterial genomes, suggests that decaprenylphosphoryl-*D*-arabinose synthesis is essential in all mycobacteria (Crellin et al., 2011). Overall, this study further validates DprE1 as a promising target for

Although many potential drug targets have been already identified, greater efforts are required in target validation to properly show their essentiality for bacterial growth and survival (Williams and Duncan, 2007). A rational antibiotic design strategy should aim to identify targets for which the resistance mechanism has the most negative effect on fitness, as in the case of the DprE1 enzyme. In fact, our data suggest that DprE1 is an optimal target also for MDR- and XDR-TB strains. The treatment of these strains is difficult if not impossible nowadays and could instead be defeated by a drug targeting *dprE1* gene product. The disruption of this essential ring in the construction of the mycobacterial cell wall makes the pathogen weak and completely unable to survive in a hostile environment, such as the macrophage. Moreover, decaprenylphosphoryl-*D*-arabinose is the only known Ara*f* donor in the biogenesis of arabinogalactan and lipoarabinomannan in mycobacteria

It is worth mentioning that decaprenylphosphoryl-*D*-arabinose is a lead molecule for the design of substrates' analogs for mycobacterial arabinosyltransferases and of new inhibitors (Wolucka, 2008). Since 2004, the synthesis of decaprenylphosphoryl-*D*-arabinose analogs as antitubercular agents has been performed. Even if these molecules inhibit mycobacterial growth, their effect was not satisfactory (Centrone and Lowary, 2004). Other efforts have been made by researchers in order to interfere with arabinogalactan and lipoarabinomannan biosynthesis. Indeed, in 2009 Pathak and co-workers reported the synthesis of modified Ara*f* disaccharides as substrates and inhibitors of *M. tuberculosis* arabinosyltransferases (Pathak et al., 2009). Furthermore, Ayers and collaborators synthesized β-arabino glycosyl sulfones,

(Mikusova et al., 2005).

new anti-mycobacterial drugs.

and is thus an essential precursor.

2009; Christophe et al., 2009; Magnet et al., 2010).

The inexorable rise in cases of tuberculosis worldwide highlights the need for new drugs and, in particular, for those that can shorten the duration of treatment. Recently, two new promising antitubercular drugs were developed (Makarov et al., 2009; Christophe et al., 2009). Both these drugs have the same cellular target, the DprE1 of *M. tuberculosis* (Manina et al., 2010b). The preclinical development program of benzothiazinone lead (BTZ043) has already begun and this class of drugs is very promising.

Moreover, another class of antitubercular drugs has been shown to have DprE1 as target, the benzoquinoxalines (Magnet et al., 2010).

This highlights the vulnerability of DprE1 and its importance as an antitubercular target.

## **6. Acknowledgment**

We thank the European Commission for support (VI Framework, contract N. LSHP-CT 2005- 018923 and VII Framework, contract N. 260872).

## **7. References**


Fighting Against Resistant Strains: The Case of Benzothiazinones and Dinitrobenzamides 289

Jarlier, V. & Nikaido, H. (1994). Mycobacterial cell wall: structure and role in natural

Lamichhane, G.; Tyagi, S. & Bishai, W. R. (2005). Designer arrays for defined mutant

Lenaerts, A. J.; Degroote, M. A. & Orme, I. M. (2008). Preclinical testing of new drugs for

Lienhardt, C.; Vernon, A. & Raviglione, M. C. (2010). New drugs and new regimens for the

Magnet, S.; Hartkoorn, R. C.; Székely, R.; Pató, J.; Triccas, J.A.; Schneider, P.; Szántai-Kis, C.;

1994), pp. 11-18, ISSN 0378-1097.

2008), pp. 48-54, ISSN 0966-842X.

16, No. 3, (May 2010), pp. 186-193, ISSN 1070-5287.

(June 2006), pp. 1134-1138, ISSN 0305-7453.

pp. 1172-1185, ISSN 0950-382X.

3108, ISSN 0929-8673.

2315-2326, ISSN 1350-0872.

9567.

resistance to antibiotics. *FEMS Microbiology Letters*, Vol. 123, No. 1-2, (October

analysis to detect genes essential for survival of *Mycobacterium tuberculosis* in mouse lungs. *Infection and Immunity*, Vol. 73, No. 4, (April 2005), pp. 2533-2540, ISSN 0019-

tuberculosis: current challenges. *Trends in Microbiology*, Vol. 16, No. 2, (February

treatment of tuberculosis: review of the drug development pipeline and implications for national programmes. *Current Opinion in Pulmonary Medicine*, Vol.

Orfi, L.; Chambon, M.; Banfi, D.; Bueno, M.; Turcatti, G.; Kéri, G. & Cole ST. Leads for antitubercular compounds from kinase inhibitor library screens. *Tuberculosis (Edinburgh, Scotland)*, Vol. 90, No. 6, (November 2010), pp. 354-360, ISSN1472-9792. Makarov, V.; Manina, G.; Mikušová, K.; Möllmann, U.; Ryabova, O.; Saint-Joanis, B.; Dhar,

N.; Pasca, M. R.; Buroni, S.; Lucarelli, A. P.; Milano, A.; De Rossi, E.; Belanova, M.; Bobovska, A.; Dianišková, P.; Kordulakova, J.; Sala, C.; Fullam, E.; Schneider, P.; McKinney, J. D.; Brodin, P.; Christophe, T.; Waddell, S.; Butcher, P.; Albrethsen, J.; Rosenkrands, I.; Brosch, R.; Nandi, V.; Bharath, S.; Gaonkar, S.; Shandil, R. K.; Balasubramanian, V.; Balganesh, T.; Tyagi, S.; Grosset, J.; Riccardi, G. & Cole, S. T. (2009). Benzothiazinones kill *Mycobacterium tuberculosis* by blocking arabinan synthesis. *Science*, Vol. 324, No. 5928, (May 2009), pp. 801-804, ISSN 0193-4511. Makarov, V.; Riabova, O. B.; Yuschenko, A.; Urlyapova, N.; Daudova, A.; Zipfel, P. F. &

Möllmann, U. (2006). Synthesis and antileprosy activity of some dialkyldithiocarbamates. *The Journal of antimicrobial chemotherapy*, Vol. 57, no. 6

Skovierová, H.; Dianišková, P.; Mikušová, K.; Marák, J.; Makarov, V.; Giganti, D.; Haouz, A.; Lucarelli, A. P.; Degiacomi, G.; Piazza, A.; Chiarelli, L. R.; De Rossi, E.; Salina, E.; Cole, S. T.; Alzari, P. M. & Riccardi, G. (2010a) Biological and structural characterization of the *Mycobacterium smegmatis* nitroreductase NfnB, and its role in benzothiazinone resistance. *Molecular Microbiology*, Vol. 77, No. 5, (September 2010),

Decaprenylphosphoryl-β-D-ribose 2'-epimerase from *Mycobacterium tuberculosis* is a magic drug target. *Current Medicinal Chemistry*, Vol. 17, No. 27, (2010), pp. 3099-

Paepe, D.; Tropis, M.; McNeil, M.; Daffé, M. & Houssin, C. (2008). Partial redundancy in the synthesis of the D-arabinose incorporated in the cell wall arabinan of *Corynebacterineae*. *Microbiology*, Vol. 154, No. Pt 8, (August 2008), pp.

Brennan, P. J.; McNeil, M. R. & Crick, D.C. (2005). Decaprenylphosphoryl arabinofuranose, the donor of the *D*-arabinofuranosyl residues of mycobacterial

Manina, G.; Bellinzoni, M.; Pasca, M. R.; Neres, J.; Milano, A.; Ribeiro, A. L.; Buroni, S.;

Manina, G.; Pasca, M. R.; Buroni, S.; De Rossi, E. & Riccardi, G. (2010b).

Meniche, X.; de Sousa-d'Auria, C.; Van-der-Rest, B.; Bhamidi, S.; Huc, E.; Huang, H.; De

Mikusova, K.; Huang, H.; Yagi, T.; Holsters, M.; Vereecke, D.; D'Haeze, W.; Scherman, M. S.;


Böttger, E. C. & Springer, B. (2008). Tuberculosis: drug resistance, fitness, and strategies for

Caminero, J. A.; Sotgiu, G.; Zumla, A. & Migliori, G. B. (2010). Best drug treatment for

Chim, N.; Habel, J. E.; Johnston, J. M.; Krieger, I.; Miallau, L.; Sankaranarayanan, R.; Morse,

Christophe, T.; Jackson, M.; Jeon, H. K.; Fenistein, D.; Contreras-Dominguez, M.; Kim, J.;

*Scotland)*, Vol. 91, No. 2, (March 2011), pp. 155-172, ISSN 1472-9792.

*Pathogens*, Vol. 5, No. 10, (October 2009), p. e1000645, ISSN 1553-7366. Cole, S. T.; Brosch, R.; Parkhill, J.; Garnier, T.; Churcher, C.; Harris, D.; Gordon, S. V.;

Crellin, P. K.; Brammananth, R. & Coppel R. L. (2011). Decaprenylphosphoryl-*b*-D-ribose 2'-

De Rossi, E.; Aínsa, J. A. & Riccardi, G. (2006). Role of mycobacterial efflux transporters in

Fenistein, D.; Lenseigne, B., Christophe, T.; Brodin, P. & Genovesio A. (2008). A fast, fully

Gillespie, SH. (2007). Tuberculosis: evolution in millennia and minutes. *Biochemical Society Transactions*, Vol. 35, No. Pt 5, (November 2007), pp. 1317-1320, ISSN 0300-5127. Goldman, R. C.; Plumley, K. V. & Laughon, B. E. (2007). The evolution of extensively drug

*Disorders Drug Targets*, Vol. 7, No. 2, (June 2007), pp. 73-91, ISSN 1871-5265.

*Cytology*, Vol. 73, No. 10, (October 2008), pp. 958-964, ISSN 1552-4922. Fischbach, M. A. & Walsh, C. T. (2009). Antibiotics for emerging pathogens. *Science*, Vol.

325, No. 5944, (August 2009), pp. 1089-1093, ISSN 0036-8075.

141-148, ISSN 0340-6199.

1998), pp. 537-544, ISSN 0028-0836.

(January 2006), pp. 36-52, ISSN 0168-6445.

e16869, ISSN 1932-6203.

global control. *European Journal of Pediatrics*, Vol. 167, No. 2, (February 2008), pp.

multidrug-resistant and extensively drug-resistant tuberculosis. *The Lancet infectious diseases*, Vol. 10, No 9, (September 2010), pp. 621-629, ISSN 1473-3099. Centrone, C. A. & Lowary, T.L. (2004). Sulfone and phosphinic acid analogs of

decaprenolphosphoarabinose as potential anti-tuberculosis agents. *Bioorganic & Medicinal Chemistry*, Vol. 12, No. 21, (November 2004), pp. 5495-5503, ISSN 0968-0896.

R. P.; Bruning, J.; Swanson, S.; Kim, H.; Kim, C. Y.; Li, H.; Bulloch, E. M.; Payne, R. J.; Manos-Turvey, A.; Hung, L. W.; Baker, E. N.; Lott, J. S.; James, M. N.; Terwilliger, T. C.; Eisenberg, D. S.; Sacchettini, J. C. & Goulding, C. W. (2011). The TB Structural Genomics Consortium: a decade of progress. *Tuberculosis (Edinburg,* 

Genovesio, A.; Carralot, J. P.; Ewann, F.; Kim, E. H.; Lee, S. Y.; Kang, S.; Seo, M. J.; Park, E. J.; Skovierová, H.; Pham, H.; Riccardi, G.; Nam, J. Y.; Marsollier, L.; Kempf, M.; Joly-Guillou, M. L.; Oh, T.; Shin, W. K.; No, Z.; Nehrbass, U.; Brosch, R.; Cole, S. T. & Brodin, P. (2009) High content screening identifies decaprenyl-phosphoribose 2' epimerase as a target for intracellular antimycobacterial inhibitors. *PLoS* 

Eiglmeier, K.; Gas, S.; Barry, C. E. 3rd; Tekaia, F.; Badcock, K.; Basham, D.; Brown, D.; Chillingworth, T.; Connor, R.; Davies, R.; Devlin, K.; Feltwell, T.; Gentles, S.; Hamlin, N.; Holroyd, S.; Hornsby, T.; Jagels, K.; Krogh, A.; McLean, J.; Moule, S.; Murphy, L.; Oliver, K.; Osborne, J.; Quail, M. A.; Rajandream, M. A.; Rogers, J.; Rutter, S.; Seeger, K.; Skelton, J.; Squares, R.; Squares, S.; Sulston, J. E.; Taylor, K.; Whitehead, S. & Barrell, B. G. (1998). Deciphering the biology of *Mycobacterium tuberculosis* from the complete genome sequence. *Nature*, Vol. 393, No. 6685, (June

epimerase, the target of benzothiazinones and dinitrobenzamides, is an essential enzyme in *Mycobacterium smegmatis*. *PLoS ONE*, Vol. 6, No. 2, (February 2011), p.

drug resistance: an unresolved question. *FEMS Microbiology Review*, Vol. 30, No. 1,

automated cell segmentation algorithm for high-throughput and high-content screening. *Cytometry Part A: the journal of the International Society for Analytical* 

resistant tuberculosis (XDR-TB): history, status and issues for global control. *Infectious* 


**13** 

**Quinolone Resistance in Tuberculosis** 

*1Département de Biologie Structurale et Chimie, Institut Pasteur, Paris* 

*3Univ Paris Diderot, Sorbonne Paris Cité (Cellule Pasteur), Paris* 

*6CNR des Mycobactéries et de la Résistance des Mycobactéries aux* 

Fluoroquinolones are key antibiotics for the second-line treatment of multidrug-resistant tuberculosis (MDR-TB), i.e. resistant to the two most powerful antituberculous drugs currently available, isoniazid and rifampicin (WHO, 2001; 2011). Unfortunately, extensively drug resistant strains (XDR-TB), defined as MDR-TB with bacillary resistant to any fluoroquinolones and to one of the three injectable second line anti-TB drugs (amikacin, kanamycin or capreomycin), are emerging worldwide (Center for Disease Control and Prevention, 2006). XDR-TB strains constitute a major concern for public health since they are virtually untreatable and responsible for up to 100% of deaths. Besides being increasingly popular in treatment of tuberculosis complicated by intolerance or by relative contraindication for first-line drugs, fluoroquinolones are under studies to shorten the duration of treatment or replace first line drugs in susceptible tuberculosis. Newer fluoroquinolones such as moxifloxacin have already demonstrated potential for shortening

treatment duration (Rustomjee et al., 2008; Conde et al., 2009; Dorman et al., 2009).

hence the second generation of drugs was called the fluoroquinolones (Fig. 1).

Fluoroquinolones are also one of the most widely prescribed antibiotics as they are generally well tolerated with high oral bioavailability plus broad-spectrum antibacterial activities against genitourinary infections and against common respiratory tract pathogens. Structurally, these drugs contain a quinoline ring system and hence are given the name quinolones (Fig. 1). After the first generation of drugs were found to be active, it was noted that a fluorine atom at the 6-position of the quinoline ring imparted greater potency, and

**1. Introduction** 

**1.1 Fluoroquinolones in tuberculosis treatment** 

**Treatment: A Structural Overview** 

Claudine Mayer1,2,3 and Alexandra Aubry4,5,6

*2URA 2185 du CNRS, Paris* 

*4UPMC Univ Paris 06, ER5, Laboratoire de Bactériologie, Paris 5AP-HP, Hôpital Pitié-Salpêtrière,* 

*Antituberculeux, Paris* 

*France* 

*Laboratoire de Bactériologie-Hygiène, Paris* 

arabinan, is formed via a two-step epimerization of decaprenylphosphoryl ribose. *Journal of Bacteriology*, Vol. 187, No. 23, (December 2005), pp. 8020-8025, ISSN 0021- 9193.

